BALANCING INNOVATION AND MARKET ACCESS: THE CONVERGENCE AND CONFLICT OF IP AND COMPETITION LAW
Abstract
BALANCING INNOVATION AND MARKET ACCESS: THE CONVERGENCE AND CONFLICT OF IP AND COMPETITION LAW
AUTHORS - ADV MONICA MADAAN* & ARRYAN MOHANTY**
* LLM STUDENT OF KR MANGALAM UNIVERSITY, GURUGRAM
** STUDENT OF SYMBIOSIS LAW SCHOOL, NAGPUR
BEST CITATION - ADV MONICA MADAAN & ARRYAN MOHANTY, BALANCING INNOVATION AND MARKET ACCESS: THE CONVERGENCE AND CONFLICT OF IP AND COMPETITION LAW, ILE COMPETITION AND COMPANY LAW JOURNAL, 3 (1) OF 2025, PG. 31-46, APIS – 3920-0028 | ISSN - 2583-8385.
Abstract
The intersection of intellectual property (IP) rights and competition law creates a complicated legal environment where the motivation for innovation must be weighed against the potential for market domination. While IP laws provide exclusive rights to creators and inventors, competition law seeks to prevent market behaviours that could negatively impact competition and consumer interests. The Competition Act of 2002 empowers the Competition Commission of India (CCI) to avoid agreements restricting competition and to address the exploitation of dominant market positions. Although IP rights are crucial for technological advancement and creativity, these rights are not unlimited and may be constrained if their application leads to anti-competitive effects. The TRIPS Agreement recognises that specific licensing practices such as exclusive grant-back clauses, coercive package licensing, or conditions that dissuade challenges to patent validity can restrict competition and hinder the spread of technology. National legislation, including the Indian Competition Act, includes measures to regulate such practices. Indian courts have highlighted that the Competition Act and IP laws like the Patents Act function in their respective areas but can also enhance each other when needed. Anti-competitive behaviours like tie-in arrangements, exclusive supply and distribution contracts, refusal to engage in dealings, and resale price maintenance are examined under Section 3 of the Competition Act unless they involve reasonable limitations to safeguard IP rights. However, when IP rights are misused to unfairly restrict competition, such as through discriminatory pricing or denying market access, Section 4 of the Competition Act comes into play. Courts have acknowledged that the misuse of IP-driven market dominance can be addressed under the Competition Act and patent laws via mechanisms such as compulsory licensing. Ultimately, the simultaneous application of IP and competition regulations highlights the necessity of harmonising private innovation incentives with the public interest in a competitive marketplace.