Publication Ethics & Governance Charter
Institute of Legal Education (ILE) and its scholarly journals strictly adhere to the guidelines established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), University Grants Commission (UGC) academic integrity regulations, and international open-access standards.
1. Double-Blind Peer Review Policy
To eliminate bias regarding author gender, nationality, institutional affiliation, or academic seniority, all ILE journals follow a strict Double-Blind Peer Review procedure. Reviewers evaluate manuscripts without knowledge of author identity, and authors receive anonymized referee reports.
2. Plagiarism Screening & AI Usage Policy
Institute of Legal Education maintains a strict zero-tolerance policy against intellectual piracy, text recycling, and uncredited attribution:
- Similarity Limit: The overall similarity index must be strictly less than 10% excluding quotations, statutory provisions, and bibliographic references.
- Pre-Submission Screening: Every paper is audited through our PlagAudit engine prior to assigning peer reviewers.
- AI Transparency: Authors who employ generative artificial intelligence tools for drafting assistance must explicitly state the tool name, version, and prompt methodology in their acknowledgments. AI tools cannot be listed as co-authors.
3. Authorship & Contributor Integrity
Authorship credit must reflect substantial individual contribution to the conception, doctrinal framework, empirical data collection, or critical analysis of the manuscript. "Gift authorship", "ghost authorship", and commercial drafting services are strictly prohibited.
4. Retraction, Corrections & Errata Protocol
Following COPE guidelines, if pervasive errors, ethical breaches, or fraudulent legal citations are uncovered post-publication:
- Minor Typographical / Citation Errors: Addressed via an official formal Erratum note published alongside the article record without altering historical text.
- Substantial Non-Fraudulent Amendments: May be processed through the formal Paid Correction protocol via the central ILE Journal Manager, generating updated PDF releases with revision timestamps.
- Irremediable Ethical Breaches: An official Retraction Notice is permanently posted, and indexing agencies are formally informed.
5. Open Access Licensing & Archival
All published articles are released under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). Authors retain copyright of their research while granting Institute of Legal Education an irrevocable first-publication license and archival rights in perpetuity.