Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-164 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access

CHILD SUPPORT & CHILD INCARCERATION IN INDIA

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2022 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, CHILD SUPPORT & CHILD INCARCERATION IN INDIA, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2022).

Abstract

Author –  YAZHINI.S, Student at GOVERNMENT LAW COLLEGE, DHARMAPURI.

INTRODUCTION:

Every person has the right to basic necessities for a dignified existence. Everyday, thousands of youngsters are detained in adolescent prisons; many more are detained in adult prisons and jails. In some circumstances, children may commit a crime because of committing crime their future should not end up with prison. They should take care of their future. Many criminals are using children for committing the crimes due to short time imprisonment and less punishment. In this article, we talk about child support, Supreme Court guidelines, provisions, child maintenance, case laws, Child incarceration.

CHILD SUPPORT:

Children are defined as anybody under the age of 14 by the Indian census. No child under the age of 14 may work in a factory or mine, or in any other dangerous employment, according to the constitution article 21. Child support arises only when the child’s parents decide to get the divorce. When it comes to the children who are left at home due to parental incarceration suffer the risk. The child support system states that whether parents who have never been married, then both the parties shall pay for the child support as per their financial status. In case if any one of them is not capable of paying, they can seek support and re-evaluate their circumstances based on the change in situations.

CHILD MAINTENANCE:

Section 125 of the criminal procedure code recognizes child maintenance in

India. If any person with sufficient resources neglects or refuses to maintain his legitimate child or illegitimate child, whether married or not, unable to maintain itself, as per section 125(1)(b) of the code of criminal procedure, or as per section 125(1)(c)of the code, person to make a monthly allowance for the maintenance of his or her legitimate or illegitimate child who has reached majority, where such child is unable to maintain itself due to any physical or mental abnormality or injury, person to make a monthly allowance for the maintenance of such child, at such monthly rates as the magistrates sees proper, and to pay the same person the magistrate sees fit from time to time.

A child, whether legitimate or illegitimate, married or unmarried, has the right

to ask his or her parents for support. In case of divorces, custody of the kid is not an automatic result of divorce. Instead one must apply to the court for custody of the child, which varies by religion. The court mostly bases its decision on the best interest and welfare of the child. The custody of a child depends upon the guardians and wards act, 1890 read with his/her respective personal laws. However, courts also try to avoid separating siblings. Different religions in India have their own specific laws. Hindus are governed by the Hindu minority and guardianship act 1956 (HMGA), Christians are governed by the Indian divorce act, 1869. As per Muslim personal laws, minor children are given to mothers. Sole custody allows only one spouse, joint custody allows both spouses to share custody. If one is given custody, the other spouse gets visitation rights.

PROVISIONS:

Section 125 of the criminal procedure code recognises child maintenance in India.

  • THE INDIAN CONSTITUTION:
  • FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS:

ARTICLE - 14

Article 14 of the Constitution ensures equal opportunities for development of all children during the period of growth should be our aim, for this would serve our larger purpose of reducing inequality and social justice.

ARTICLE -15

Article 15 (3) provides that this shall not prevent the state from making any special provision for women and children. So, special provisions are to be made by the state for the upliftment of children and convicted persons.

  • DIRECTIVE PRINCIPLES OF STATE POLICY:

ARTICLE - 38 STATE TO SECURE A SOCIAL ORDER FOR THE PROMOTION OF WELFARE OF THE PEOPLE

ARTICLE -39 CERTAIN PRINCIPLES OF POLICY TO BE FOLLOWED BY THE STATE

Article 39(f) – Provides that children are given opportunities and facilities to develop in a healthy manner and in condition of freedom and dignity and that childhood and youth are protected against exploitation and against moral and material abandonment.

ARTICLE - 41 RIGHT TO WORK, TO EDUCATION AND TO PUBLIC ASSISTANCE IN CERTAIN CASES.

The duty to take effective steps to provide education has acquired special significance in view of the recognition of a fundamental right to education partly in terms of this article. Now a citizen has a right to call upon the state to provide educational facilities to him within the limits of its economic capacity and development.

ARTICLE -45 PROVISION FOR EARLY CHILDHOOD CARE AND EDUCATION TO CHILDREN BELOW THE AGE OF SIX

Article 45 stipulates that the state shall endeavor to provide early childhood care and education for all children until they complete the age of six years.

  • CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE:

Section 27 – Anyone under the age of 16 at the time of their appearance before the court is not subject to death or life imprisonment.

  • THE INDIAN PENAL CODE, 1860:

Section 82 – Act of a child under seven years of age

Nothing is an offense which is done by a child under seven years of age.

Section 83 – Act of a child above seven and under twelve of immature understanding.

Nothing is an offense which is done by a child above seven years of age and under twelve, who has not attained sufficient maturity of understanding to judge the nature and consequences of his conduct on that occasion.

JUVENILE JUSTICE ACT, 2015:

The act establishes a complex structure of caring for children who have been neglected or abused. The act mandates that neglected minors be brought before the juvenile welfare boards established under the act, which serves as a court of magistrates.The act permits juveniles between age group of 16 to 18 to be tried as adults for henious offences.The gang-rape case that happened in Delhi brought a number of changes in Indian criminal justice system.

1.CHILD IN CONFLICT WITH LAW:

The ‘juvenile’ in conflict with law has been substituted with ‘child’ in conflict with law. A child in conflict with law will be sent to an observation Home temporarily during pendency of inquiry and a place of safety will be setup for children above the age of 18 and it will have separate arrangements and facities for under trial children and convicted children.The juvnile justice Board will conduct regular inspection of jails meant for adults to check if any child is lodged in such jails and will take immediate measures for transfering the child to observation home[section 8(3)(m)

The act mandates that in case the child is tried as adult by the Children’s court,it shall ensure that final order includes an individual care plan for rehabilitation of child.After attaining the age of 20 if the term is still pending,the children’s court shall evacuate that whether the child should be transferred to jail or has undergone reforative changes and could be spared incarceration.

2.CHILDREN IN NEED OF CARE AND PROTECTION:

A child in need of care and protection is to be produced before the Child welfare committee within 24 hours and then the child will be placed in a children’s home for care,treatment,education,training,development and rehabilitation.The act provides for open shelters for children in need of community support on short term basis for protecting them from abuse or keeping them away from a life on the streets. The Specialized Adoption Agency is to take care of the rehabilotation of orphans, abandoned or sureendered children.

SUPREME COURT GUIDELINES FOR CHILDREN OF PRISONERS:

On 13 th April, 2006, a three judges bench in R.D. Upadhyay V. State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors[1], In this case after taking into considerations various reports, affidavits and submissions, the Supreme Court laid down the following guidelines:

  • A jail must have adequate facilities for prenatal and postnatal care for female prisoners as well as their children.
    • Gynecological examination of female prisoners shall be carried out in the District Government Hospital. Bona fide prenatal and postnatal care shall be provided to the prisoner as per Medical practitioner’s advice.
    • It should not be mentioned in the birth certificate of the child that he is born in prison, just the address of locality will be recorded.
    • Inside the prisons, children should be able to acquire shelter, food etc…, medical assistance when essential, education and a creche or recreational space.
    • Children on a regular basis should be examined by a lady medical officer to keep a tab on their physical growth and secure timely vaccination, while logging vaccination records. Supplementary clothing, diet, etc…, must be provided via Medical officer’s recommendation.
    • Children can live with women prisoners up to the age of six. After that they should be ceded over to welfare institutions run by the social welfare department, ideally in the same town or city.
    • The children can live in such an institution pending his/her mother’s release or if the child is competent enough to earn a livelihood.
    • The Director of the Social Welfare Department, shall ensure that the concerned children kept under protective custody in care homes shall be sanctioned to meet their mother at least once a week.
    • The State Legal Services Authorities shall take imperative measures to intermittently inspect jails to oversee acquiescence with the directions regarding children and mothers.
    • Where probable and feasible, provisional release or parole arrangements or suspension of sentence in case of casual offender/ minor offender should be made to allow an expectant prisoner to have here delivery outside the prison. This arrangement can be deprived of a prisoner only in exceptionally high risk cases.

RELEVANT CASE LAWS:

JAGADISH JUGTAWAT V. MANJU LATA[2]

In this case the court held that Section 125 of Cr.P.C. doesn’t fix any liability over doesn’t fix any liability over the parents for the child above 18 but reading Section 125 of crpc with Section20(3) of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance act, 1956 the girl being major and unmarried is entitled to have maintenance from her parents.

NOOR SABHA KHATOON V. MOHD.QUASIM[3]

In this case, the court held that Muslim children are entitled to maintenance under Crpc. It was held that benefit under Section 125 of Crpc is available to all children irrespective of religion. Under Muslim Women (Protection of rights on divorce) Act, 1986 the mother has right to claim maintenance of children for two years from their date of birth and it is distinct and independent of the right to maintenance under Crpc to minor children who are unable to maintain themselves.

BAKULABAI V.  GANGARAM[4]

In this case, the court held that bigamous marriage is illegal under Section 11 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 but when both the parties are loving together as husband and wife for several years and give birth to the child, that child attain a legitimate status under Section 16 of the same act and hence the bigamous child is entitled to maintenance under Section 125 of Crpc.

PADMJA SHARMA V. RATAN LAL SHARMA[5]

In this case, it was decided that a Hindu working woman is also responsible for her children’s upkeep. Under the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956, a Hindu divorced Father and a Hindu Divorcee earning mother are both required to contribute to the upkeep of their children. Regardless of whether or not their mother is capable of earning, the father is not solely responsible for the children’s upkeep.

KULABI IBRAHIM V. STATE OF COIMBATORE[6]:

The Court held that the juvenile at any point of time during the trial has the right to raise the question of juvenility even after the disposal of the case under provision of Section 9 of Juvenile Justice Act, 2015.

CHILD INCARCERATION INDIA:

DUE TO PARENTS:

According to a research conducted by the Indian government in 2015, India’s prison house 419,623 inmates, of whom 4.3 percent, or around 18,000 are women.This study raised concerns about the children in prison with their mothers and addressed crucial questions about the basic human rights that such youngsters are afforded. Different states have different age restrictions for children kept with their mother in prison. In Assam, children are allowed to stay with their mother until six years of age. In Bihar, children are allowed to stay with their mother in prison until two years of age. Special medical facilities to care for these children are not enough in some areas due to not sufficient economical resources. Special services like food, medical, and education are lacking in some prisons for women who keep their children.

  • DUE TO DELINQUENCY:

Due to various psychological or environmental factors, a child ends up committing a minor crime. No child under the age of seven can commit a crime, because a child under that age is presumed to be doli incapax, or incapable of exercising judgment.

The juvenile justice act establishes a complex structure for caring children who have been neglected or abused. The scheme for prevention and control of juvenile social maladjustment has been implemented by the ministry of welfare to provide financial support to states/union territories for the establishment of observation homes / aftercare organizations.

The juvenile justice act, according to the justice Verma committee report on “amendments to criminal law”, has failed miserably to protect minors in the country. We cannot hold a child liable for a crime before we have provided him/her with the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Indian constitution.

CURRENT STATUS:

According to an investigation and the Supreme Court ruling in 2006, minor amendments had been made to the treatment of women prisoners of children. Due to this, a few prison departments started with providing fortified food and crech and necessary services.However several convict mothers are still hesitant about sending their children to this facilities.Despite the limited public funds and other issues,several non-governmental organisations have sought to improve the living conditions of children in prisons by providimg them with,for example, a smooth transition from jail facilities to resedential schools.In a few states,the government has brought NGOs to support impoverished prisoners.

CONCLUSION:

Childhood is an important stage for every child in their life where the child

learns so much. In terms of the child maintenance legislation, as both parents have equal rights to the child because they both contribute to the child’s upkeep, no one should suffer as a result of separation or divorce. In the child support system, both parents must petition for joint custody because they must both contribute financially and economically to the child, but in the event of a small child, the mother has the first claim to the child because she is the one who gave birth to it. Considering this, there must be improvements and implementations in child incarceration and child support laws as every person has the right to live with human dignity.

REFERENCES:

  1. R.D. Upadhyay V. State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors, 2006 (4) SCALE 336
  2. Jagadish Jugtawat V. Manju Lata, (2002)5 SCC 422
  3. Noor Sabha Khatoon V. Mohd. Quasim, (1997)6 SCC 233
  4. Bakulabai V. Gangaram, (1988)1 SCC 537
  5. Padmaja Sharma V. Ratan Lal Sharma, (2004) SCC 266
  6. Kulabi Ibrahim V. State of Coimbatore, AIR 2014 SC 2726
  7. UNICEF, Early childhood development : Real life from around the world, New York, 2011.
  8. Devika Sharma, Maintenance-children and parents, Jan 10, 2019.
  9. https://indiankanoon.org/doc/116184888/
  10. INDIA CONST. art.14
  11. INDIA CONST. art.15
  12. INDIA CONST. art.38
  13. INDIA CONST. art.39
  14. INDIA CONST. art.41
  15. INDIA CONST. art.45
  16. Indian Penal Code, S.82
  17. Indian Penal Code, S.83
  18. Juvenile Justice Act, 2015

[1] R.D. Upadhyay V. State of AndhraPradesh & Ors, 2006(4)SCALE 336

[2] Jagadish Jugtawat V. Manju Lata, (2002)5 SCC 422

[3] Noor Sabha Khatoon V. Mohd.Quasim, (1997)6 SCC 233

[4] Bakulabal V. Gangaram, (1988)1 SCC 537

[5] Padmaja Sharma V. Ratan Lal Sharma, (2004) SCC 266

[6] Kulabi Ibrahim V. State of Coimbatore, AIR 2014 SC 2726

← Back to Repository Search