BEYOND STATUTES AND SCHEMES: ANALYSING INDIA’S LEGAL AID MECHANISMS AND ACCESS TO JUSTICE
Abstract
BEYOND STATUTES AND SCHEMES: ANALYSING INDIA’S LEGAL AID MECHANISMS AND ACCESS TO JUSTICE
AUTHOR - ABDULLAH GHAZALI* & KEERTHI S**
* ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, SCHOOL OF LAW, PRESIDENCY UNIVERSITY
** CONTRACT MANAGEMENT PROFESSIONAL, SIEMENS INDIA
BEST CITATION - ABDULLAH GHAZALI & KEERTHI S, BEYOND STATUTES AND SCHEMES: ANALYSING INDIA’S LEGAL AID MECHANISMS AND ACCESS TO JUSTICE, JOURNAL ON VULNERABLE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, 3 (1) OF 2025, PG. 48-55, APIS – 3920 – 0020 | ISSN – 2583 – 8067.
1. INTRODUCTION
Democratic societies are founded on strong ideals of justice and the rule of law. These ideals shape reality through justice institutions such as courts and tribunals. The justice institutions have evolved over centuries, shifting the paradigm of legal jurisprudence. Throughout the modern history of the Indian judiciary, the privileged class appointed by the British imperialists occupied the key positions.[1] In the decade after the commencement of the Indian constitution (1950), things started to change. Through the forty-second amendment (1976), Article 39A was added to the constitution.[2] Making free legal aid a ‘Directive Principles of State Policy’ (DPSP).
Access to justice is central to achieving equity in democratic societies.[3] It ensures equal access to justice for all citizens, regardless of socioeconomic and religious status. The democratic ideals of the rule of law, equality and fairness, accountability and development of trust between individuals cannot be achieved without Access to Justice.
The privileged class can secure justice, but the vulnerable and marginalised are left out of the justice system.[4] This happens due to inherent bias against the marginalised and the vulnerable. It is further aggravated by institutional and procedural biases serving as barriers to access to justice. Justice delivery will not reach its constitutional goal unless people experiencing poverty and vulnerability have access to justice. Women and children are among the most impacted by access to legal aid, as inherent vulnerabilities in the legal system require focused protection and inclusion within justice mechanisms. India's constitutional commitment to legal aid remains far from reality.
Systemic barriers continue to hinder legal aid in India.[5] Legal Aid in India lacks basic infrastructure and is significantly underfunded. India's National per capita expenditure on Legal Aid is 6.46 rupees.[6] There are fewer legal aid clinics in rural areas than urban areas, which has propelled an overburden of legal service clinics in rural areas. Data between 2017 and 2024 suggests a steep increase in the average number of villages per rural clinic across the country, increasing the workload on the legal service clinics.[7]
[1] Mr. Justice S. S. Dhavan, The Indian Judicial System: A Historical Survey,
https://www.allahabadhighcourt.in/event/TheIndianJudicialSystem_SSDhavan.html
[2] India Const. Art. 39A.
[3] Alan S Gutterman, What is Access to Justice? SSRN (February 17, 2022), https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4050575
[4] Krishnan, P.S., Social Exclusion and Justice in India, Routledge India, 1st ed., 2017.
[5] Krishnaswamy, S. et al., Legal and Judicial Reform in India: A Call for Systemic and Empirical Approaches, 2(1) Journal of National Law University Delhi, 1-25 (2018).
[6] India Justice Report 2025, pp. 119, https://indiajusticereport.org/files/IJR%204_Full%20Report_English_Low.pdf.
[7] India Justice Report 2025, pp. 126, https://indiajusticereport.org/files/IJR%204_Full%20Report_English_Low.pdf.