ENVIRONMENTAL RACISM AND STRUCTURAL INJUSTICE: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF LEGAL ACCOUNTABILITY
Abstract
ENVIRONMENTAL RACISM AND STRUCTURAL INJUSTICE: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF LEGAL ACCOUNTABILITY
AUTHOR - ABHINAV VISWANATH* & KRUTHA JANANI**
* ASSISTANT PROFESSOR AT SASTRA UNIVERSITY
** STUDENT AT SASTRA UNIVERSITY
BEST CITATION β ABHINAV VISWANATH & KRUTHA JANANI, ENVIRONMENTAL RACISM AND STRUCTURAL INJUSTICE: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF LEGAL ACCOUNTABILITY, INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LEGAL RESEARCH JOURNAL, 4 (1) OF 2026, PG. 45-56, APIS β 3920 β 0011 | ISSN - 2584-1904.
ABSTRACT
Environmental racism refers to the disproportionate burden of environmental harm placed on marginalized communities, often structured by caste, race, ethnicity, or indigeneity. Despite growing global awareness of environmental injustice, these patterns remain deeply embedded in legal, political, and economic systems. This study investigates international expressions of environmental racism through case studies from the United States, Canada, and Nigeria with a critical lens examining persistent structural inequities in Indiaβs environmental governance. These cases reveal consistent patterns in which marginalized populations are subjected to hazardous industrial activity, inadequate public services, and regulatory neglect. From the siting of polluting industries in the tribal and marginalized regions of India and Canada, to the water crisis in Flint, Michigan, and oil extraction in the Niger Delta, environmental racism manifests through both historical marginalization and contemporary governance failures.
The paper adopts a sociolegal framework to assess the role of domestic and international legal instruments in responding to these injustices. Laws such as Forest Rights Act of India, the Civil Rights Act of the United States, and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples are examined regarding their scope, implementation, and limitations. While these frameworks articulate important rights and protections, they fall short in practice where enforcement is uneven, participatory mechanisms are weak, and regulatory bodies are vulnerable to political or corporate capture.
Addressing environmental racism requires moving beyond procedural formalities toward a substantive vision of environmental justice. This includes mandating equity within environmental impact assessments, ensuring inclusive justice for affected communities by strengthening governance. The study argues for a transformative legal and institutional approach that prioritizes structural change through a comprehensive framework. Comparative insights underscore the need for legal systems to recognize and provide remedial mechanisms addressing the social and spatial distribution of environmental harm, and to support community-led efforts toward ecological justice.
Key Words: Environmental Racism, Caste and Environment, Regulatory Injustice, Indigenous Rights, Environmental Justice