Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-391 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access

The Protection Of Identity In Cyberspace And The Issue Of Cybersquatting

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2022 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, The Protection Of Identity In Cyberspace And The Issue Of Cybersquatting, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2022).

Abstract

Author - Mansi Gaba, Student from Asian Law College.

INTRODUCTION

An identity is a proof of one’s existence and everyone has the exclusive right over their identity. An act of identity theft occurs when a person is alleged to steal the identity when he/she impersonates another person who they are not.  

It is an offence of using someone else’s identity for the purpose of committing fraud, conducting any other unlawful acts or taking undue advantage of someone else’s goodwill and reputation. It is a conventional crime covered under Section 419 and 420 of the IPC which interprets identity theft as cheating and is equally punishable since it is cheating by impersonation.

However, this class of crime only enhanced over a period of time due to the technological advancement in society. In the contemporary internet world, it has become much easier to steal and misuse another person’s identity. Identity thieves often use internet technology to obtain other people's personal information or trademark for identity fraud. The cases for identity theft are increasing every day since the cyberspace widen the scope for easy stealing of identities+. 

TYPES OF IDENTITY THEFT

Many other crimes are initiated with the offense of identity theft. Hence, it is rarely a single crime but is composed of the commission of a wide variety of other crimes. The crimes with which identity theft is commonly associated are: check and card fraud, financial crimes of various sorts, various telemarketing and Internet scams, theft of autos and auto parts aided by fraudulent documentation, thefts or robberies of various kinds where the identification information is stolen either by coincidence or intentionally, counterfeiting and forgery, trafficking in human beings and terrorism.

Following are the type of identity thefts:-

  • Criminal Identity Theft; takes place when the perpetrator illegally uses the stolen identity of the victim to commit any unlawful act that may damage the life or property of the victim.
  • Financial Identity Theft occurs when the perpetrator uses the financial identity of the victim such as his security number, credit card, bank details etc.  to commit fraud or cheating relating to bank accounts, insurance and such other.
  • Identity Cloning and Concealment, perpetrators can use the information they obtained to hide their real identity. They can request and use identification instruments to mislead investigation or use the victim’s bank account to launder money.
  •  Synthetic Identity Theft occurs when the perpetrator uses fake information along with stolen identity to create a new identity which is used for illegal activities. Sometimes multiple information is stolen from various people to create a synthetic identity.
  • Medical Identity Theft occurs when the criminal uses the information of someone else to get prescription drugs, see the doctor or claim the insurance benefit. It effects the medical records of the victim.

IDENTITY THEFT UNDER INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ACT, 2008

The term ‘identity theft’ was added into the Information Technology Act, 2000, after its amendment in 2008. Section 66C of the IT Act, defines and prescribes punishment for the offense of identity theft.

Definition: ‘Whoever, fraudulently or dishonestly make use of the electronic signature, password or any other unique identification feature of any other person

 Punishment: shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years and shall also be liable to fine which may extend to rupees one lakh.’

Another section of the aforesaid act which punishes for cheating by impersonation is section 66- D which defines the offence and prescribes the punishment for it as follows

Definition: ‘Whoever, by means for any communication device or computer resource cheats by personating,

Punishment: shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years and shall also be liable to fine which may extend to one lakh rupees.’

The offenses under the above sections are cognisable, bailable and triable by the Magistrate of the First Class. These new amendments recoganaise the challenge for identity theft in cyber space. Hence, the cases of e-mail fraud, creation of fake profiles in social media websites or applications for the purpose of cheating, e-mail forgeries, data theft, breach of privacy by unauthorized access and other such cases are punishable under section 66-B, 66-C, and 66-D.  One of the relatively new yet fastly spreading online identity theft is the act of cybersquatting.

CYBERSQUATTING AND IPR

Domain name refers to the unique internet addresses which are used to find the websites and also act as an identifier for the business entities. It directs the online sufferers to particular websites that may associate to some business entities.  Websites are the new emporium for the business as it brings traffic of customers that eventually help them to expand. However, it is observed that identity thieves often steal the domain name of the registered trademarks in order to gain the undue advantage of the goodwill and reputation of original trademark owner. This act is also famously known as cybersquatting.

Cybersquatting, as defined by Indian judiciary, refers to an act of obtaining fraudulent registration of a domain name with intent to sell it to the lawful owner of the name at a premium. Such a domain name is confusingly similar to or dilutive of an already registered offline trademark or personal name. Altogether, it is an act of registering domain names to prevent the owner of that trademark from using it in cyber space. It is often done with the malice intention to extort money from the original owner or to malign the reputation of the owner. Further, cybersquatting is also of various types including domain name squatting, typo squatting and name-jacking. In India, cybersquatting was first brought to judiciary’s attention in Yahoo Inc. v Aakash Arora & Anr.  In this case, the defendant started a website with the domain name YahooIndia.com providing services similar to the Plaintiff. On a suit filed by the Plaintiff, the court ruled in favour of Yahoo. Inc (the Plaintiff) and observed, “it was an effort to trade on the fame of yahoo’s trademark. A domain name registrant does not obtain any legal right to use that particular domain name simply because he has registered the domain name, he could still be liable for trademark infringement.”

This High Court decision was taken to its culmination and perhaps a step forward by the Supreme Court of India in Satyam Infoway Ltd. v Sifynet Solutions.  In this case, the Respondent registered two domain names, www.siffynet.com and www.siffynet.net, deceptively similar to the Plaintiff’s domain name ‘www.sifynet.com’. ‘Sify’ was first used by the plaintiff as an acronym of its trade name Satyam Infoway. This name had immense goodwill in the market. On a plea by the Plaintiff, the Supreme Court, held “Domain names are business identifiers, serving to identify and distinguish the business itself or its goods and services and to specify its corresponding online location.” This case is a landmark one because the recognized that domain harbours all the features of a trademark and allowed the Plaintiff’s claim in on basis of the principle of passing off.

In another landmark case of Samdeep Varghese v, State of Kerala, ‘www.jaypolychem.org’ was the original website of the complainant’s company but another website with the name ‘www.jayolychem.org’ was made by the accused (who was dismissed from the company). Defamatory and malicious matters were published in the website with the intention to malign the name of the company. This deception caused the defamation and financial loss to the complainant’s company.

Internet is the latest hub for commercial activities. Hence, a domain name plays a really important role as a business identifier. It helps identifies the websites for specific business and even an attempt to create confusion for the users will cause a lot of financial loss to the business entities. Therefore, the value of maintaining an exclusive identity becomes critical. “As more and more commercial enterprises trade or advertise their presence on the web, domain names have become more and more valuable and the potential for dispute is high."

CONCLUSION

The constant rise in the crime of identity theft eventually affects the legal and fundamental rights of the victims at a deeper level. It is necessary to curb it before it rises too high. Laws are difficult to enforce in cyberspace but it is not impossible. Stricter provisions and quicker actions will somehow alert the identity thieves. Also, it is important to give more recognition to the domain names as a trademark and the principle of trademark laws shall apply for the protection of domain names. The menace of identity theft must be countered at the earliest.

References

  • A Jain, (2005). Cybercrime Issues Threats and Management, India, Chawla Offset Publication
  • Chawki et al, (2006). Identity theft in cyberspace: Issues and solutions
  • Ankita Shrivastava, Identity Theft in Cyberspace with Special Reference to India, Vol 8 2020, ISSN 2581-5504.
  • Rupal Jaiswal, “The Web of Cybersquatting: Do we need a Law to clean it?”, Vol 6,2019
  • ISSN 2581-5504
  • Dr SR Myneni, Information technology law (cyber laws), 1st Edition, Asia law house
  • R.P. Kataria, S.K.P.Srinivas,” Cyber Crimes Law Practice and Procedure”, Orient Publishing Company2013
  • Indian Penal Code, 1860 Information Technology Act , 2008
← Back to Repository Search