How Eco-friendly Indian Courts are?
Abstract
Authos – Mrinal Kumar, Student from Amity Law School, Ranchi (Amity University Jharkhand).
Introduction
The environment, which includes water, air, and soil, dictates the presence, development, and improvement of mankind and all of its activities. The idea of environmental conservation and preservation is not new. It was fundamental to many ancient civilizations. Ancient Indian literature emphasize that it is the dharma of each member in society to safeguard nature, and the phrase "nature" covers land, water, trees, and animals, all of which are vital to humans. The ancient Hindu Scepters declared in the 'Atharva Veda', "What of thee I dig out, let it soon grow over."
At the same time, new developments like as thermal power, atomic power, and so on that lack enough natural assurance offer additional threat to the situation, resulting in difficulties such as global warming, climate change, acid rain, and so on. Furthermore, the Indian legislature's tendency to pass a slew of measures rather than address the root causes of failure and disappointment, and continuously passing new acts is akin to putting "old wine in a new bottle." As a result, there is a need for a complete review of environmental protection. In recent years, there has been a persistent focus on the role of the higher courts in creating and supervising the execution of pollution control, forest conservation, and animal protection policies. Many of these judicial interventions have been prompted by policy incoherence as well as a lack of capacity-building within executive agencies. Public Interest Litigation (PIL) has been widely used to address environmental issues, and this strategy has both proponents and detractors.
The Role of the Indian Judiciary in the Development of Environmental Jurisprudence
Professor Upendra Baxi, who has frequently praised Indian judicial activism, has also stated that the "Supreme Court of India" has frequently become the "Supreme Court for Indians." The Judiciary, by its powers and action, has actively contributed to the strengthening of the basic rights guaranteed by the Constitution. Furthermore, the Stockholm Conference on Human Environment, 1972, led to the building of India's environmental legislation framework and served as a catalyst for the passage of the 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1972. This amendment imposed specific environmental obligations on citizens (Article 51A(g)) as well as the state (Article 48A).
The legal standing of Articles 51(A)(g) and 48A under the constitutional system is enabling in nature and not legally binding per se; nonetheless, such articles have frequently been construed as legally binding by Indian courts. Furthermore, the courts have utilized these clauses to justify and build a legally binding basic right to the environment as part of the right to life under Article 21. The Supreme Court extensively mentioned various international laws in the Asbestos Industries Case, including the ILO Asbestos Convention of 1986, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948, and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights of 1966. In this case, the court addressed questions about occupational health dangers for workers in asbestos businesses. The court ruled that such employees' right to health constitutes a basic right under article 21 and provided precise instructions to the authorities. The Calcutta High Court held in the Calcutta Wetland Case that India, as a signatory to the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands, 1971, is obligated to encourage wetlands protection.
Do Indian Courts Practice Sustainable Development?
This question is very complex to answer because, In India we have total of 672 District courts and 25 High Courts and 1 Supreme Court including “N” numbers of tribunals and benches of different High Courts and this makes the question quite difficult to answer, Every court in India practice its own set of rules and regulations and every courts stand is different on going Environmental friendly, it’s basically depends on the Judge or the Presiding Offices of the courts on how they practice this concept of sustainability, Let’s take example of one court “The Delhi High Court” To enhance faster delivery of justice, the Delhi High Court is slated to become the country's first paperless e-court. The suggestion was implemented by a committee comprised of Justices Badar Durez Ahmed, S. Murlidhar, Anil Kumar, and Rajiv Sahai Endlaw.
According to the group, it would not only be environmentally beneficial, but would also contribute in the rapid administration of justice.
This is only about one court, but soon in future we will be going to witness this in Majority of Indian Courts. The main problem with going paperless is the habit of using/reading and convenience of the paper itself, when I was doing my internship in one of the High Court in India, I realized that the Advocates, Judges as well as the Court Master is in a habit of using paper for printing a document which contains a single word!!! The is the current situation of sustainability in High Court of Indian, In one of the Study by Mr. Chaitanya Mallapur
Which states that Printing Paper on Both Sides in SC Cases = Saving 2,000 Trees, 24,000 Tankers of Water
How Printing on both side of the paper will save paper or resources? In Context of Supreme Court of India
According to Ruth Anne Robbins' 2010 paper, Conserving the Canvas: Reducing the Environmental Footprint of Legal Briefs by Re-imagining Court Rules and Document Design Strategies, a tree produces 8,333 sheets of virgin—non-recycled—paper, while a piece of paper requires 10 liters (2.6 gallons) of water to create.
With just two parties each case in the Supreme Court, eight sets of files would be required—four for the court and one each for the parties and their lawyers. If each petition is 100 pages long, a total of 49.2 million papers are required.
This equates to 5,906 trees being utilized to produce 49.2 million sheets of paper. Using double-sided paper would have saved 2,953 trees and 246 million liters of water.
The quantity of water saved could feed 12 million people – the population of Bengaluru, a city that might run out of water in 12 years – with their daily water requirement of 20 liters for cooking and drinking.
Bengaluru receives 100 liters of water per person per day, of which only 20 liters are utilized for cooking, drinking, and bathing. The remaining 80 liters are utilized for non-potable uses such as cleaning floors, flushing toilets, and vehicle washing.
According to a 2010 Asian Development Bank report, India is expected to fall 50% short of fresh water demands by 2030.
"Paper goods constitute the majority of municipal solid trash," according to the petitions.
"India is one of the world's largest trash producers, producing about one lakh metric tons of waste paper per day." In India, just 27% of waste paper is utilized, implying that the remaining 73% is tossed unused."
Between July 4, 2018 and August 4, 2018, 1,504,528 cases were filed in India, comprising subordinate courts (1,391,426) and high courts (113,102). Using paper printed on one side for 50 pages each case and six sets would have resulted in over 451 million pages, or 54,165 trees. Using double-sided paper would have saved 27,083 trees and 2,257 million liters of water—nearly 58 percent of Mumbai's daily water supply needs (3,900 million liter per day). "The Supreme Court is exploring becoming paperless in stages," P P Chaudhary, minister of state for law, justice, and corporate affairs, said in a reply to the Lok Sabha (parliament's lower chamber) on July 25, 2018.
"In 2013, the Supreme Court began a paperless work environment by introducing an e-office." Following the adoption of digital filing, the Supreme Court of India created the Integrated Case Management Information System (ICMIS) in 2017."
Following the deployment of the ICMIS, digitized case records from the high courts can now be transferred to the Supreme Court. However, digitalisation, such as scanning of case data, including new petitions, is still ongoing, according to the ministry.
While the Supreme Court launched e-filing in May 2017, "the process could not materialise due to non-digitisation of documents in high courts," according to the PIL before SC.
"It was suggested that one may file an appeal in the Supreme Court by filling up simply the grounds of the appeal, and the Supreme Court would acquire the complete preceding record straight from the high court’s using digital methods," CASC general secretary Gaurav Pathak told IndiaSpend.
"The high courts have not been able to digitize all of their records/case documents since there are numerous cases, especially older ones, with thousands of pages that are difficult to scan and upload."
What Can We Do About It?
The first step, of course, would be to begin printing on both sides. The other, longer-term option is to digitize court materials. This will have several advantages, including:
- Increasing transparency in court proceedings.
- Preventing the loss of court papers.
- Lower courts, high courts, and the Supreme Court will all have access to court documents at the same time.
- Courts will be able to handle cases more quickly.
In reality, the Supreme Court started e-filing in 2017, but the process was halted. Why? Because high court records were not being digitized.
Why? Because they lacked the personnel to scan and upload case papers totaling lakhs of pages!
While some judges have requested that papers from their courtrooms be recycled during the previous decade, this has been the exception rather than the norm.
To summarize: our courts consume a lot of paper, and our courts should care more about our trees and water.
Reference
- People United For Better Living In Calcutta v. East Kolkata Wetlands Management Authority, AIR 1993 Cal 215.
- District Courts In India - Introduction, Hierarchy & Composition Available at: <https://legodesk.com/legopedia/district-courts-in-india/#:~:text=There%20is%20a%20total%20of,jurisdiction%20of%20the%20High%20court.> <Last visited on 30 June 2022>
- High Courts of India Available at: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_courts_of_India> <Last visited on 30 June 2022>
- Delhi High Court set to go paperless available at: <https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/delhi-high-court-set-to-go-paperless-61753-2009-11-27> <Last visited on 30 June 2022>
- Mallapur, C., 2022. Printing Paper On Both Sides In SC Cases = Saving 2,000 Trees, 24,000 Tankers Of Water: Study. [online] Indiaspend.com. Available at: <https://www.indiaspend.com/printing-paper-on-both-sides-in-sc-cases-saving-2000-trees-24000-tankers-of-water-study/> <Last visited on 1 July 2022>
- Robbins, R., 2010. Conserving the Canvas: Reducing the Environmental Footprint of Legal Briefs by Re-imagining Court Rules and Document Design Strategies. Journal of the Association of Legal Writing Directors, [online] 7(2010), pp.1-10. Available at: <https://ssrn.com/abstract=1650128> <Last visited on 1 July 2022>.
- Asian Development Bank. 2011. ADB Annual Report 2010. [online] Available at: <https://www.adb.org/documents/adb-annual-report-2010> <Last visited on 1 July 2022>.
- Aphis.usda.gov. 2022. [online] Available at: <https://www.aphis.usda.gov/brs/aphisdocs/dicamba_deis.pdf> <Last visited on 1 July 2022>.
- Honig, J., 2022. How Going Paperless Reduces Your Company’s Carbon Footprint. [online] Start.docuware.com. Available at: <https://start.docuware.com/blog/document-management/how-going-paperless-reduces-your-companys-carbon-footprint> <Last visited on 2 July 2022>.
- Whitney, W., 2022. Digitizing Court Records | Secure Scanning & Conversion. [online] BMI Imaging - Document Management Company. Available at: <https://bmiimaging.com/blog/document-management/digitizing-court-records> <Last visited on 1 July 2022>.