<strong><em><u>Revisiting a not-so-popular case of Anurag And Co. and Ors. Vs. Add. Dist. Judge And Ors, AIR 2006 RAJ 119: Descriptively analyzing the interplay of sections 10 and 151 of CPC.</u></em></strong>
Abstract
Revisiting a not-so-popular case of Anurag And Co. and Ors. Vs. Add. Dist. Judge And Ors, AIR 2006 RAJ 119: Descriptively analyzing the interplay of sections 10 and 151 of CPC.
Author - Miss. Yashi Jain, Student of Marwadi University, Rajkot, Gujarat.
ABSTRACT
The present descriptive case analysis deals with the Judgment of the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the case of Anurag And Co. and Ors. Vs. Addl. Dist. Judge And Ors, AIR 2006 RAJ 119. The interplay of section 10 and section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure is the essence of the matter issue in the present case. The legal significance of the present case is that it has categorically laid down the relevant circumstances for consolidating civil suits which are directly aiding to understand the principle of res sub judice enumerated under section 10 of the code. The researcher has summarily commented on the issues before the Hon’ble High Court that importantly deals with section 10 of the CPC based on which the court passed its judgment. The three broad issues that the researcher elaborates on are the crux of the rationale in the present case.
- INTRODUCTION
Section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure establishes the doctrine of res sub judice, which refers to the stay of a lawsuit in a certain court. The competent authority can put a stay on the trial in the court where the suit was later instituted if two cases with exactly the same parties and the same matter in issue have been filed in two different courts with concurrent jurisdiction. In this instance, the court where the suit was first filed and is still pending will have the authority to make the decision. It aids in ensuring that no two courts rule on the same matter, as their decisions may differ due to concurrent litigation. The present case deals with the matter of consolidation of suits by an application moved by the petitioner/defendant to the Hon’ble Rajasthan High court whereby they challenged the order of the Additional District Judge that refuses to consolidate four civil suits for the recovery of money. Although the Code of Civil Procedure doesn’t expressly mention through any provision about the Consolidation of suits, courts can order the same by under their inherent powers to meet the ends of justice and or to prevent abuse of the process of the court. However, these required conditions for using the inherent powers must exist.
The legal significance of the present case is that it has categorically laid down the relevant circumstances for consolidating civil suits which are directly aiding to understand the principle of res sub judice enumerated under section 10 of the code.
FACTS OF THE CASE
BACKGROUND OF THE CASE
- The respondents in the present civil writ petition are different plaintiffs who had filed separate civil suits against the petitioners-defendants for recovery of different amounts that become due on different dates. All these civil suits were pending before the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Sikar. Hereinbelow are the details of the suit:-
| Sr no. | Title of the Suit | No. of Suit | Amount Recoverable |
| 1. | Vinod Kumar Sharda vs. Anurag and Company | 98/2001 | 4,30,254/- |
| 2. | Arun Kumar vs. Anurag and Company | 36/01 | 2,75,935/- |
| 3. | Sanjay Kumar Sharda vs. Anurag and Company | 37/01 | 3,40,274/- |
| 4. | Parwati Devi Sharda vs. Anurag and Company | 94/2001 | 2,12,725/- |
- In all the above civil suits the cases were fixed for the evidence of the petitioners-defendants.
APPLICATION FILED BY THE PETITIONERS-DEFENDANTS UNDER SECTION 10 READ WITH SECTION 151
- On or around 4th December 2004 an application was filed by the petitioners-defendants in all civil suits under section 10 read with section 151 on the ground that all civil suits are common, the subject matter is the same, and evidence of the defendant (petitioner) will be identical in all the four suits and in case all the suits are tried separately then there is the possibility of conflicting findings/judgments.
- In reply the respondents-plaintiffs state that defendants are not common and there are no possibilities of conflicting judgments as the respondents-plaintiff have any objections if all the suits are heard simultaneously.
FACTS GIVEN RISE TO THE PRESENT CIVIL WRIT PETITION
- On July 18, 2005, the Additional District Judge in Sikar denied the application for consolidation, stating that when the plaintiffs are different in all four civil suits, the causes of action are different, the amounts are different, and that simply because the defendants are the same, such civil suits cannot be consolidated because there is no provision in Section 10 CPC or any other CPC provision to consolidate such civil suits. As a result, the application was denied. Hence, by the present writ petition, the petitioners have challenged this order.
ISSUES INVOLVED IN THE PRESENT CASE
The court in the present case broadly has to deal with the following issues:
- Whether the present civil writ petition maintainable before the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court?
- Whether the Trial Court has committed an error in not consolidating the civil suits?
- Whether there exist the circumstances in the present four civil suits that can be consolidated?
- Whether the present case suffices the essentials of res-sub-judice to fall within the ambit of section 10 of the Civil Procedure Code?
RATIONALE OF THE PRESENT CASE
The rationale of the present case is –
The court held that in the instant case neither the parties are the same nor the cause of action is the same, nor the burden of proof is on the same person, but the burden of proof is on the different respondents-plaintiffs. Therefore, it cannot be said that the matter in issue is substantially and directly the same between the same parties. Further, some of the relevant circumstances for consolidating the civil suits are:
- The parties should be substantially the same.
- There should be complete or even substantial or even sufficient similarity between the issues arising for decision in the two suits.
- Common evidence is to be led, if parties are substantially the same, if only one party is common then the burden of proof of facts in the issue will be on a different person and no common evidence can be led.
- Lastly, if any other circumstances may be relevant then also the object of consolidation will be decisive for passing the appropriate order.
COURT’S HOLDING
The court held that “keeping in view the abovementioned relevant circumstances and object of the consolidation, there is no substantial similarity between the parties and issues involved as present suits are between different parties wherein cause of actions arose on different dates, the burden of proof is on a different person and further, the consent is given by the respondent-plaintiff for simultaneous hearing of the four dull suits pending before the same Court, which will eliminate the chances of conflicting Judgments, and hence, non-consolidation will not defeat the object of the consolidation of the suit. Therefore, the trial court was correct to not consolidate the civil suits”.
ANALYSIS OF THE JUDGMENT
In the present case, the petitioner has approached the court by way of the writ petition claiming him being aggrieved by the decision passed by the Additional District Judge, Sikar from which his request for the consolidation of the pending suits was rejected. It is a settled principle observed in the case on the object of the consolidation of suits that it is to protect the parties to the suit from facing a multiplicity of proceedings, delays, and bore unnecessary expenses for which the courts can use their inherent powers under section 151 of the CPC to pass such orders as to meet the ends of justice and prevent abuse of the process of the court. Both the parties, plaintiffs and the defendants have placed reliance on several High courts and the Supreme court judgments and they were very well clear on the stand that the civil courts have inherent powers to consolidate the civil suits but they had their analysis on whether the circumstances exist in the present four civil suits to consolidate them or not. To the obviousness, petitioners tried to answer it as yes, consolidation is applicable in the present case and the same was contested by the defendants.
The court here examined whether the present set of facts is qualified for the consolidation of the suits by analyzing the various judgments cited by the parties before the Hon’ble High court. Accordingly, the common line on which the court needs to test the present set of facts for consolidation is summarized as follows:-
(a) Whether the parties in all the four instituted civil suits are same?
(b) Whether the same cause of action is arising in all the civil suits?
(c) Whether the burden of proof of issues is on the same person in all the civil suits?
a. WHETHER THE PARTIES IN ALL THE FOUR CIVIL SUITS ARE SAME?
For qualifying, this condition both the parties to the suits should be the same. Here it is per se evident that in all the civil suits that are pending before the Additional District Judge, Sikar the plaintiffs are substantially different. Section 10 of CPC implies that the court is barred to try a subsequently instituted suit if the matter in issue in the previously instituted suit is directly and substantially between the same parties. But here in the present set of facts, the claim of the consolidation of suit by the plaintiff doesn’t stand which Hon’ble High court has well pointed out.
b. WHETHER THE SAME CAUSE OF ACTION IS ARISING IN ALL CIVIL SUITS?
Cause of action in simple words can be stated to be the bundle of facts that refers to the violation of a legal right of the plaintiff by the defendants. These are the set of facts based on which a lawsuit is filed against defendants. The Hon’ble Supreme court in the case of Rajasthan High Court Advocates vs Union Of India & Ors while dealing with the meaning of the cause of action has mentioned that, “The expression means every fact which it would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, to support his right to the judgment of the Court. Every fact which is necessary to be proved, as distinguished from every piece of evidence which is necessary to prove each fact, comprises in the cause of action”.
In the present case, it is evident that when the plaintiffs are different their cause of action to bring suit for the recovery of money against the defendant is also different even arising on the different dates. A similar observation was made by the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court where two suits for the different periods for the recovery of rents were instituted by the plaintiff and the court held that the two suits would not be deemed to be the same and Section 10, CPC, would not be applicable. Therefore, the Hon’ble court has rightly observed the difference in the cause of actions of the plaintiff in the present case that further eliminates the ground for consolidation of the suit.
c. WHETHER THE BURDEN OF PROOF OF ISSUES IS ON THE SAME PERSON IN ALL THE CIVIL SUITS?
The burden of proof in all four civil suits is entirely on different parties. Therefore, as rightly been pointed out by the court that the plaintiff isn’t able to establish the grounds or existence of any circumstances that would enable a court to use its inherent powers and cure the failure of justice. Nor the plaintiff can satisfy how the separate trial of the suit will lead to complications.
Hence, the Hon’ble High Court has correctly considered the present case as not the case where consolidation of suits is possible and rightly ratified the decision passed by the Trial court and dismissed the present writ petition.
CONCLUSION
The researcher would like to conclude by mentioning that in the present case the Hon’ble Rajasthan High court has extensively dealt with the purpose of consolidation of suits by analyzing the various cases put before it and has substantially drawn the scope of consolidating the suit by laying down a few important circumstances for consolidating any civil suit. Moreover, as it is observed by the Hon’ble Delhi High Court that there is of course no straight jacket formula to differentiate the cases that can be either stayed or consolidated under section 10 or 151 of CPC as it all ultimately depends on the wise of the judge to take a judicial decision that is guided by the experience. If consolidation of suits would make the trial complicated or prejudice the rights of the parties to the suit may be because either the parties are not common or the issues are not common, the court may not prefer the consolidation as it happened in the present case. But it may be preferred where it is advantageous to do the same.
Hence, the present case is relevant as it will aid the courts and the parties dealing with the consolidation of suits in future cases as the court has expressly laid down the relevant circumstances for consolidating the civil suits.
Endnotes
- The Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s 151.
- The Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s 10.
- Anurag And Co. and Ors. Vs. Addl. Dist. Judge And Ors, AIR 2006 Raj 119.
- Chitivalasa Jute Mills v. Jaypee Rewa Cement, AIR [2004] SC 1687.
- Rajasthan High Court Advocates vs Union Of India & Ors, AIR 2001 SC 416.
- Sri Bhola Prasad vs Srimati Jagpala And Anr, AIR 1955 All 384.
- S.C. Jain vs Bindeshwari Devi, 1997 (42) DRJ 239.