Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-690 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access

<strong>Evolution of Data Protection Laws: The Need of the Hour</strong>

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2023 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, <strong>Evolution of Data Protection Laws: The Need of the Hour</strong>, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2023).

Abstract

Evolution of Data Protection Laws: The Need of the Hour

Authors - Gautam Kumar, Student of ICFAI Law School, Hyderabad & Pritam Kumar, Student of National Univesity of Study and Research in Law, Ranchi

I. Introduction

Improvement of technology has made dramatic changes in the way we interact with the present world. Gone are days of paper and pen contracts, physical transaction, and penning postage mails to stay in touch with the long-distance relatives. Technology has made these cheaper, convenient and reliable.

In the Current world data plays an essential role and the protection of data has become a red-hot topic of everyday newspapers.

But every good thing comes with its own demerit. With the increase in digital technology, there has also been an evolution and increse in cyber related crime. This made people reluctant to conduct business or any transaction in the electronic form due to lack of appropriate legal frame work. Hence, it was seen that there was an urgent requirement of Legal Framework that would enable to country to facilitate e-commerce.

II. Citizens or Netizens

The internet has made enabled us to blend in with people from different parts of the world irrespective of citizenship. The term ‘Netizen’ is a portmanteau of the English words’ internet and citizen. It may be pertinent to mention that most of the cyber crimes are committed cross border but India lacks in co-operation in cyber crime matter as it has not signed any Cyber Crime Conventions. It becomes very difficult to try any person outside Indian Jurisdiction. Signing the Cyber Crime Convention will expedite processing of cooperation requests made by India from other jurisdictions.[1]

 III.            Domain Name Disputes

Whether starting a big Corporate Farm or a small entrepreneurship, in the internet world, it beings with registering of Domain Names. Domain Name, in simple words, can be defined as the addresses of the internet. Because of the established popularity of the internet, every new organization wants a domain name matching to the name of the organisation. Govt. can intercept communication

It has been seen that all these lacunas posing a major question to the cyber-Law of the country i.e. ‘Is the Data of the netizens of the country secure?’ If the answer is ‘Yes’, then who is accountable for it and if the answer is ‘No’ then the Fundamental Right to Privacy is a myth in this digital world. Whether there is misuse of power of the police given by this act or Govt. using the data in the name of security, sovereignty or integrity of the country, the real loss is to the netizens of the country as their data is always at the stakes.

No doubt the Information Technology Act,2000 is a great achievement and a remarkable step ahead in the right direction. The Act had been made with the sole purpose kept in mind that this Act will help the country for commencing of E-Commerce. Data Privacy was never the concern. But with the growth of the internet and digital world, it has become high time for us to think about it.

 IV.            Comparing Indian laws with foreign land

A.    Japan

In year 2017, Japan came up with legislation for Data Protection termed as Act on the protection of Personal Information (APPI). It is applicable to states institutions, local Public Bodies, Independent Administrative agencies and an entity not having over 5,000 individual’s Personal Information for more than six months. Consent of the concerned party and right to Privacy forms the essence of the same legislation. [2] One thing that we can adopt here is the scope of this Act’s power which includes institutions of state as well as local bodies.

B.     USA

   In a study conducted by Pew Research Centre in 2018, it was found that Half of the Americans believe, their personal data is less secure and government should come up with amendments in the existing data protection laws. Some of the recent cases of Data breach are as follows, after which USA came up with Data Protection Act 2020 for Personal Data Privacy and Security.

In January 2020, Restaurant conglomerate Landry’s announced a Malware Attack on which several Personal Data were targeted like Card holder’s name, debit card numbers, credit card numbers, expiree date, CVV etc.

Paaya was a card processor start-up of Use. In its initial days company managed to get 2.5 million customers but Paay left the database of its customer accessible online without password. Under database it included Name of the customer, card number, expiree date, CVV and amount spent on particular transaction [3]

For the same reason and the other USA amended its existing legislation regarding data protection. New legislation termed as Consumer Data Privacy and security Act 2020. Act started with the purpose of data privacy, in this new law personal data were separately defined. Highlights of the Consumer Data Privacy and Security Act 2020 are as follows: -

Consent for collection and processing of personal data could be explicit or implicit, but consent must be obtained by the consumer. As per the present CDPSA 2020 privacy policy must be made public clearly so that it may understood by all consumer. Further it includes the limit of permission, it Covers entities and service providers may collect or process personal data without an individual’s consent to the extent reasonably necessary and limited to a defined Permissible Purpose. It also includes The CDPSA designates the FTC as the federal agency in charge of administering the CDPSA and grants its rule making authority and provides a mechanism for additional personnel and resources to assist with administering the CDPSA.[4]

Conclusion/ Suggestions to the issues of Standard forms of Contract

No customers in a thousand ever reads these conditions. If one had stopped to do so, it would consume his priceless time in today’s fast paced world. This gives a unique opportunity to the giant companies to exploit the weaknesses of the individuals by imposing upon them the terms that often look like a kind of private legalization and which may go to the extent of exempting the company from all liability under the contract.[5] This leads to exploitation of the consumers. A bigger problem regarding this kind of potential data scam is unawareness of consumers regarding what these applications and websites are capable of and reluctance to fight a legal battle as a result of this. And this unawareness results from unwillingness to read the terms or speedy skimming over of the privacy terms with only a small fraction of population desiring to sit and read the terms. And considering the monotonous and hectic work of our daily lives it is almost always unreasonable to even expect a consumer to read the full text or even assume that they have actually consented to anything mentioned. For example: in Twitter’s privacy policy, it is clearly mentioned that one can control the kind of information that they are sharing with the application but problem lies with the amount of awareness and concern that people lack. Most of them don’t even think that it is important to go through these contents of privacy policy before clicking on “I Agree” button. Leave twitter, but small kids who are given access to mobile phones download many games online without giving a care to go through the terms as most of them are either too small to read or are just disinterested like many adults out there, and most of the times don’t understand as the language of the content being English, children in India become fluent in this second language not before at least middle school and in many cases, not before high school.  With rising e-shopping consumers and overall consumers of services or platforms online, we really need to do something about this whole situation in India as today, there is hardly anyone who knows to live without internet.

It is very important that we look up to the definition of consent in section 13 of ICA. It states “when two parties entered into the contract there should agree upon the same thing in the same manner”.[6] Now the situation with standard form of contracts really defy the definition given, as when one of the parties does not even read your standard form of contract, you can’t say there was a consent pertaining agreement on the same thing in the same manner. And when kids go on to enter these standard forms of contracts, it defies the fact that minors can’t legally enter into a contract. In a layman’s language, consent is as simple as permission given to someone out of a person’s own free will. But if we look at complications involved with this layman explanation, we need to acknowledge that section 13 of ICA, has to be taken seriously.

A suggestion proposed to this problem is that it would be better for creating awareness regarding their privacy for consumers if owners provided each term and conditions and Privacy Policies in pictorial form, in different slides. Adding to this if option of opting out certain terms and condition which is dis-satisfactory to the user as suggested by Ministry of Electronic and Information Technology will give equal opportunity to user to negotiate with companies for their data protection, the same suggestion would also help in overcoming the disadvantages of Standard form of contract. Also, it should be mandatory to provide privacy policy in major Indian languages too along with pictorial form.

     Android applications with standard contact take permission from user to use their gallery, contacts, cookies etc. Recently famous messaging app WhatsApp updated its privacy policy which tempted the concerns of its users to focus on the terms and conditions or policies which is put forward by WhatsApp. According to new term and conditions and privacy policy put forward by WhatsApp, it will be able to share and receive a certain category of information with other companies of Facebook, such information may include mobile phone number, service-related data, transaction details, mobile device information, IP address, messages etc.[7]

Reacting to the same ministry of Electronics and Information Technology said that unilateral changes are unfair and unacceptable. Government is asked to propose changes in such a manner which giver user to opt-out certain terms and conditions with which user is dissatisfied. Government asked WhatsApp to provide details of services by it in India, categories of data collected and permissions and consents sought, adding to its government also asked WhatsApp to withdraw the proposed changes and reconsider its approach to information Privacy, freedom of choice and Data security.[8] But despite all of this because of the huge consumer base that WhatsApp has, users had to switch on to accept its new policy in February 2021 although petition against it remains pending in Supreme Court.

Date leakages poses various types of threats to different groups of Population like as per the study conducted by IPSOS Research Private Limited during the Period of February 2020, 76% of inappropriate calls and messages women receives are from unknown People. True caller (calling App) have taken an initiative to help women who is harassed by such calls and messages [$itsNotOk (for women to be harassed. Let’s put an end to this menace)][9]

Reference

  1. Karnika Seth, http://www.karnikaseth.com/wp-content/uploads/1st-Dec-2014-Lacunae-in-the-IT-Act2000-ks-final.pdf , (last visited on Nov 16, 2022).
  2. Identity Force, A Sontiq Brand, 2020 Data Breaches - The Most Significant Breaches of the Year | IdentityForce®. (Last visited Nov 22, 2021).
  3. The Quint, WhatsApp New Privacy Policy Update: ‘Use Signal App’ Emerges As A New Slogan As WhatsApp Pushes Privacy Update (thequint.com) (Nov 7, 2022)
  4. True caller, #ItsNotOk, VOL. VIII NO.17, The Times of India (TOI), 1, 2021.

[1]  Karnika Seth, http://www.karnikaseth.com/wp-content/uploads/1st-Dec-2014-Lacunae-in-the-IT-Act2000-ks-final.pdf , (last visited on Nov 16, 2022).

[2] The Indian EXPRESS, Data Protection: where in India, when it comes to legislations,   Data privacy: Where is India when it comes to legislation? | India News,The Indian Express, (last visited Nov 20, 2022.)

[3]  Identity Force, A Sontiq Brand, 2020 Data Breaches - The Most Significant Breaches of the Year | IdentityForce®. (Last visited Nov 22, 2021).

[4] Gregory M. Kratofil, Jr., Elizabeth (Liz) Harding, Federal Privacy Legislation Update: Consumer Data Privacy and Security Act of 2020, Volume XI, THE NATIONAL REVIEW, 150, (2021)

[5] Avtar Singh, Contract & Specific relief, 69(Eastern Book Company 2019)

[6] Avtar Singh, Contract & Specific relief, 69(Eastern Book Company 2019)

[7]  The Quint, WhatsApp New Privacy Policy Update: ‘Use Signal App’ Emerges As A New Slogan As WhatsApp Pushes Privacy Update (thequint.com) (Nov 7, 2022)

[8] India asks WhatsApp to Withdraw new Policy, VOL. VIII NO.17, The Times of India (TOI), 1, 2021.

[9] True caller, #ItsNotOk, VOL. VIII NO.17, The Times of India (TOI), 1, 2021.

← Back to Repository Search