Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-756 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access

<strong>A STUDY ON EVERYDAY CYBERCRIME</strong>

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2023 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, <strong>A STUDY ON EVERYDAY CYBERCRIME</strong>, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2023).

Abstract

A STUDY ON EVERYDAY CYBERCRIME

Author - Shreya Srivastava, Student at University of Allahabad

ABSTRACT

The past few decades have witnessed technological breakthrough that has brought digital revolution. As the world gets into the crave for things that are “quick and easy”, the digital age has posed threat to people’s privacy and security (Meeks, 2000). We have now unlocked our digital identities that is traced by our digital footprints. This revolution has not just changed the pace of societal functioning but also crime rates. Simultaneously, this advancement of information technologies has also brought along its use as well as criminal tool in order to perform hide, or aid unlawful or unethical activity. (DAAAM international scientific book).Criminologist Paul Tappan defines crime as “an intentional act or omission in violation of criminal law. This paper deals with understanding of cyber crime in everyday life and legal challenges ahead it.

Keywords: Cyber crime, cyber laws , cyber space

INTRODUCTION

We live in time where digital world is reshaping are identities. This provide tool to virtuous as well as to evil of society. With exceptions, every crime has at least three elements : a criminal act (actus  reus); a criminal intent (mens rea); and concurrence of two. [1]Any illegal behavior jointly with malicious and criminal intent constitute crime. Cyber space has become a pool for users to reach extreme with their illicit conduct and exploit web with criminal intent. In context to cybercrime,  we often use it interchangeably with computer crimes .Though all cybercrimes fall under computer crime , but not all computer crimes are considered cybercrimes. Within the 10th United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, two definitions were developed (Gercke, 2013): Cybercrime in a narrow sense (computer crime) covers any illegal behaviour directed by means of electronic operations that target the security of computer systems and the data processed by them. Cybercrime in a broader sense (computer-related crimes) covers any illegal behaviour committed by means of, or in relation to, a computer system or network, including such crimes as illegal possession and offering or distributing information by means of a computer system or network.[2] Another broader definition is provided in Article 1.1 of the Stanford Draft International Convention to Enhance Protection from Cyber Crime and Terrorism, which points out that cybercrime refers to acts in respect to cyber systems . [3]Every state has its own cyber laws which are national in its implementation whereas internet is borderless and international by definition , exceptionally challenging from legal perspective. Recently, computer forensics has seen growing focus on digital forensics in terms of stopping and prosecuting computer criminals. Before computer forensics has established solid processes and techniques, there were a number of computer crime cases that were not solved. The reasons for a failure to prosecute are plenty, yet the most prominent one may be that authorities are not suitably equipped to ensure the successful collection of digital evidence in terms of tools and skills. [4]

WHAT IS CYBERCRIME ?

Cyberspace has provide place to users to conduct cybercrime anywhere , anytime and with anyone in this world. Cyber crime is basically defined as any criminal activity which takes place on or over the medium of computers or internet or other technology , and this makes it exceptionally challenging as the chain or base of this crime is increasing with each passing day. An increasing number of criminals abuse the speed, convenience and anonymity offered by modern technologies so that they can commit a wide range of criminal activities. The following are included: attacks against computer data and systems, identity theft, the distribution of child pornography, Internet auction fraud, the penetration of online financial services, as well as the deployment of viruses, botnets, and various email scams such as phishing. [5]The intention of act resides within its purpose or use , the dependence of modern world on screens has made availability and access to data so easy. Attackers have control on system with such simple operations and entire command on the vulnerability of host system. We are trading off convenience for privacy and security of our information.

Complexities of cybercrime lies its own nature, including jurisdiction, national implementation of cyber laws , collection of evidence and extent up to which it can be committed , in addressing the problem of computer crime , law must be expansive enough to deter unlawful activities, while narrow enough to recognize the many legitimate uses of computers and computers network. [6]

 The non-local or borderless nature of cyber crime is a real challenge from legal aspect. Its existence in virtual world makes it difficult to control, local laws or national implementation of cyber laws will not be enough to tackle its giant nature. Jurisdictional aspect of cyber crime is still a debatable issue as State and courts lack real authority and forum to entertain such cases. Despite international conventions federal state implement their local laws , which now calls for international defensive mechanism to cope with real challenges of it.

Another problem lies in its degree of commission , virtual world provides wide open field to criminals to go on extreme as their identities are anonymous. Anonymity can lead a person to reach at peak as they commit crime by wearing the shell with another person’s name on it and this create challenge for computer crime trial as evidences may or may not be conclusive. The problem of anonymity is complicated by the fact that, in computer crime prosecutions, the integrity of computerized data is frequently in question. At one time the government is contending that the computerized information and the computer system that contains it which has been the subject of attack by the criminal defendant is vulnerable to alteration or destruction, while at the same time, the bulk of the evidence presented is frequently generated by the very same corrupted computer system. Subsequently, the problem is followed by lack of ethical behavior in cyber space.  [7]Crime emerges from the structural weakness of our society and so we are the vulnerability being exploited due to our dependence on computer system. There is a absence of structural ethics that should be developed to tell to what is admissible and what is not.  The unique feature of cyber crime which makes it  exceptionally challenging is collection of evidence. It is difficult to collect evidence and present them in court of law as evidences may or may not be conclusive in nature they are circumstantial also due this port driven society , commission of crime in virtual world makes it tangibly less traceable in physical world.  

Actus reus and mens rea are two essentials that every crime should have . Actus reus means  “the prohibited conduct or behavior that the law seeks to prevent. Although commonly referred to as the (guilty act) ” [8] While mens rea stands for ,” a culpable mental state ”. the criminal intent of one plays vital role in cyber crime and should be proved beyond any reasonable doubts, as the knowledge of doing wrong should be implied in the conduct but the borderline of intentional and unintentional act smees vague. One has to be aware of when the access is unauthorized . Often one crosses the border of authorization of data without actually knowing that he is breaking it , and such circumstances create difficulties to determine exact criminal intent.

Actus Reus in cybercrimes has become a challenge as the entire act is committed in intangible surroundings. The perpetrator may leave some footmarks in the machine itself though it becomes a herculean task for the law enforcement machinery to prove it in the courts, as it is required to be in

physical form or atleast in such a form where it becomes admissible in evidence.[9]

There are a very large number of examples of cybercrime:

· Examples of cybercrime where computers or networks are used as tools in criminal activity refer to spamming and criminal copyright crimes, particularly those enabled via peer-to-peer networks;

 · Examples of cybercrime where the target of criminal activity is the computer or network contain unauthorized access, viruses, malware (malicious code) and denial-of-service attacks;

 · Examples of cybercrime where the criminal activity’s location is the computer or network include theft of service (telecom fraud) and certain financial frauds;

· Examples of traditional crimes that are enabled by implementing computers or networks (where the primary target is independent of the computer network or device) contain fraud and identity theft, information warfare, phishing scams, child pornography, online gambling, securities fraud, etc. Cyberstalking is an instance of a traditional crime (harassment) in a new form when carried out via computer networks.[10]

CLASSIFICATION OF CYBER CRIME:

  • Cyber crimes are generally classified into four major categories :
  • Individual cyber crime : This basically aim for   individual system through phising , spoofing ,spam , cyberstalking and more.
  • Organisation Cyber crime : they aim to destroy the system of an organization these are done by group of criminals . this includes malware attack , and denial of service attacks
  • Property cyber crime includes credit cards or even intellectual property rights
  • Society cybercrimes , includes cyber terrorism
  • Phishing and scam :
  • Other cyber crime includes cyber stalking- stalking through email and stalking through internet, cyber pornography, cyber terrorism , hacking , data theft data diddling, salami aattacks, email spoofing , internet time theft , cybercrime committed through wireless technology.

LEGAL RECOGINATION OF CYBERCRIME :

   While 156 countries have enacted cybercrime legislation the pattern varies bt region; Europe has the highest adoption rate (91 percent) and Africa the lowest(72 percent).   

The Council of Europe’s (CoE) cybercrime convention is also known as the Budapest convention .This convention is a sole legally binding international multilateral treaty on cybercrime it coordinates cybercrime investigations and laid down the guidelines for any country developing comprehensive national legislation against cyber crime as a framework.

Russia-led Resolution

CYBER LAWS IN INDIA

In India, cyber laws are contained in the Information Technology Act, 2000. The main object of this Act is to provide legal recognition to e-commerce and electronic formats and to facilitate the filing of electronic records with the Government. This legislation lays down rules and regulations related to cybercrimes, electronic information and formats, electronic authentication and digital signatures, and liability of network service providers. The I.T. Act is based on the United Nations Model Law on Electronic Commerce 1996 (UNCITRAL Model) recommended by the General Assembly of the United Nations by a resolution dated 30 January 1997.

The Indian Cyber Law covers these major aspects of Cyberspace and cybercrime:

  1. The Indian Cyber Law makes every format in electronic form legal, which means anything that you write, share and publish electronically is now considered legal.
  2. It also makes all electronic contracts legal, which means that an offer can be electronically made and accepted, and it would amount to a valid and binding electronic contract.
  3. The Indian Cyber Law recognizes and legalizes the concept of digital signatures and electronic authentications. 
  4. Indian Cyber Law covers almost all kinds of cybercrimes and provides punishment for the same. 
  5. It also punishes the people of other nationalities, provided their crimes involve any computer or network situated in India.

The IT Act is the salient one, guiding the entire Indian legislation to govern cyber crimes rigorously:

Section 43 - Applicable to people who damage the computer systems without permission from the owner. The owner can fully claim compensation for the entire damage in such cases. Section 66 - Applicable in case a person is found to dishonestly or fraudulently commit any act referred to in

 section 43. The imprisonment term in such instances can mount up to three years or a fine of up to Rs. 5 lakh.

Section 66B - Incorporates the punishments for fraudulently receiving stolen communication devices or computers, which confirms a probable three years imprisonment. This term can also be topped by a Rs. 1 lakh fine, depending upon the severity.

 Section 66C - This section scrutinizes the identity thefts related to imposter digital signatures, hacking passwords, or other distinctive identification features. If proven guilty, imprisonment of three years might also be backed by a Rs.1 lakh fine.

The Cybersecurity Framework (NCFS), authorized by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), offers a harmonized approach to cybersecurity as the most reliable global certifying body. NIST Cybersecurity Framework encompasses all required guidelines, standards, and best practices to manage the cyber-related risks responsibly. This framework is prioritized flexibility and cost-effectiveness. It promotes the resilience and protection of critical infrastructure by: Allowing better interpretation, management, and reduction of cybersecurity risks – to mitigate data loss, data misuse, and the subsequent restoration costs
Determining the most important activities and critical operations - to focus on securing them Demonstrates the trust-worthiness of organizations that secure critical assets Helps to prioritize investments to maximize the cybersecurity ROI Addresses regulatory and contractual obligations Supports the wider information security program By combining the NIST CSF framework with ISO/IEC 27001 - cyber security risk management becomes simplified. It also makes communication easier throughout the organization and across the supply chains via common cybersecurity directives laid by NIST. [12]

CHALLENGES FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE IN CYBERSPACE

The scale and quantity of cyber crime , devices, users and victims: The degree of occurrence of cyber crime is growing rapidly. Estimate show that there is a cyberattack every 44 seconds throughout the day. Global cybercrime costs are expected to grow by 15% per year over the next five years, reaching $10.5 trillion annually by 2025. (Cybersecurity Ventures, 2020). The more will be our dependence on modern technology the more will be the chances of occurrence of cyber crime , we live port driven society our devices are connected to thousands of hundreds of other port , in that scenario it is easy hack the vulnerability of host system and exploit it for personal motivation, financial gains etc. to fight with crime committed in virtual world is comparatively unreal , and less controllable. But the real question is who is infected and how this disease of cyber crime is spreading. Because what is spreading this crime at this rate is infected system connected to many other. We need to install awareness regarding self cyber security and how one can understand the analogy of cyber criminals.

Technical challenges ( VPN, P2P, anonymisers, encryption, VOIP, NATs etc.)

  1. Cloud computing :  The National Institute of Standards and Technology (“NIST”) broadly defines “cloud computing” as a model for enabling ubiquitous, convenient, on-demand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources that can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort or service provider interaction. Legal issues that can arise “in the cloud” include liability for copyright infringement, data breaches, security violations, privacy and HIPAA violations, data loss, data management, electronic discovery (“e-discovery”), hacking, cybersecurity, and many other complex issues that can lead to complex litigation and regulatory matters before courts and agencies in the United States, Europe, and elsewhere.[xiii]
  2. Another challenge is territorial and jurisdiction: Traditional accounts distinguish three kinds of jurisdiction when determining the limits of a state’s jurisdictional scope; legislative jurisdiction, judicial jurisdiction and jurisdiction to enforce. Jurisdiction to enforce is generally dependent upon having judicial jurisdiction, which is dependent upon having legislative jurisdiction (Wilske & Schiller 1997). Legislative jurisdiction itself derives from a limited set of principles; territoriality, effects, personality and the protective principle. These principles are challenged in Cyberspace by their dependence on actions and consequences having identifiable geographic locations.[13]
  3. The challenge of mutual legal assistance, every federal state has its own cyber laws while internet is world wide , we need develop a structural defensive mechanism and coherent ethical structure for better understanding and implementation of cyber laws.
  4. There is also uncertainty regarding the availability of data, as when its comes to evidence collection the virtual footprints and corrupted system makes it little easy to track the criminal in real world. Also ,no data means no evidence and no evidence means no justice.

CONCLUSION

To the final verdict, it is submitted that the pace of traditional crime has changed into cyber crime which needs little more attention than crimes of physical world . As tackling such crime will need a structural implementation of cyber law at global level. We need to find the balance between the convinence and privacy of data of users. We need to sought a mechanism which will balance the right to privacy and state regulations of cyber crime. Here are numerous challenges ahead legislative system. We need understand the psychology of why cyber criminals commit such crime. And a demand of awareness among people regarding web , skills related to computer, and self security of their, data two step verification not abruptly clicking on every link . The one who commit crime is also a human and one affecting is also a human and human are the only who can break this chain.


[1]Chapter 4 -elements of crime ,Criminal law by University of Minnesota Libraries Publishing ,open.lib.umn.edu/criminallaw/chapter/4-1-criminal-elements

[2] Gercke, M. (2013). Training on Cybercrime and Discussion of the Draft Bill, Special Training on Cybercrime, 2nd Workshop on Transposition of SADC Cybersecurity Model Laws In National Laws For Namibia Windhoek, Namibia. Available from: http://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Projects/ITU-EC-ACP/HIPSSA/Documents/Special% 20Training % 20on%20Cybercrime%20%281%29.pdf (last visited on : March 5, 2023)

[3] Id at 1

[4] Čisar, P. & Čisar, S. M. (2012). General Directions of Development in Digital Forensics. Acta Technica Corvininesis-Bulletin of Engineering, 5(2) Digital Forensics Research Workshop, “A Road Map for Digital Forensics Research” 2001., Available from: www.dfrws.org

[5] Shipley, T. & Bowker, A. (2013). Investigating Internet Crimes, An Introduction to Solving Crimes in Cyberspace, ISBN: 978-0-12-407817-8 Van Solms, S.H. & Lourens, C.P. (2006). A Control Framework for Digital Forensics, IFIP 11.9

[6] Mark D. Rasch, Criminal Law and The Internet , The Internet and Business: A Lawyer's Guide to the Emerging Legal Issues, 1996, https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.805/articles/computer-crime/rasch-criminal-law.

[7] Id at 2

[8] Kermit L. Hall, The oxford companion to American law , Oxford University Press, 2004

[9] Talat Fatima, Cyber Crime (1st Edition, Eastern Book Company, Lucknow 2011 ) p. 64-68

[10] New world Encyclopaedia, https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Cybercrime,( last visited  March 05 , 2023 ).

[11] Drishtiias.com, https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis/convention-on-global-cybercrime,( last visited march 5, 2023)

[12] Appknox, https://www.appknox.com/blog/cybersecurity-laws-in-india (last visited 28 febuary, 2023)

[13] Morningstar law group, https://morningstarlawgroup.com/insights/cloud-computing-legal-issues/, (last visited 01 march 2023)

← Back to Repository Search