<strong>DEATH PENALTY – Overview</strong>
Abstract
DEATH PENALTY – Overview
Author - Shresth Kukreja, Student at Chandigarh University.
ABSTRACT
This article talks about the death penalty as the capital punishment. It also talks about the various ways by which the different countries execute death penalty. This article includes the concept and the evolution of death penalty in India. The concept of doctrine of rarest of rare cases and case laws which hold the important place in the context of capital punishment are also discussed in this article. The constitutional validity of awarding death penalty and its need is also discussed below.
KEYWORDS
Death penalty, Capital punishment, Heinous, Court, rarest of rare cases, Execution
INTRODUCTION
What is death penalty?
Capital punishment which is also known as death penalty is the highest degree of punishment which can be given to any criminal or an offender. In this, the criminal gets death as a punishment for his/her crime. This punishment can be given for the crimes which are very heinous or serious in nature.
Death penalty has come a long way. Earlier back to eighteenth century, there were many ways to execute death penalty like by burning alive, beating to death, drowning, hanging and many more. But now, many countries have found it inhumane and according to statistics given by United Nations, more than 150 countries are not using it or have already abolished death penalty as a punishment. But many countries still have it as a capital punishment as they have found it useful to reduce crime rates.
Every country sees death penalty through its own lenses and all the countries have their own views about it. Many countries consider it as a cruel decision which is against the humanity and many countries find it useful and good for the society. According to “wikipedia” “as of 2022, 55countries retain capital punishment, 109countries have completely abolished it for ordinary crimes”. Since 1976, many countries like Argentina, Philippines, Turkey, Ukraine, Canada, United Kingdom, Italy, Australia, France, Netherland, Norway, Brazil, Denmark, Portugal and many more have abolished death penalty as a punishment for all the crimes. Some countries like India, United States, Singapore, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Taiwan, Japan, China and few more have retained capital punishment for the betterment of the society.
There are several ways across the globe to execute the death penalty, which are:
- Lethal injection - this method is still use in countries like China, Thailand, Vietnam, Guatemala and Taiwan.
- Electrocution - Countries like Florida and South Carolina are using this method of death penalty.
- Lethal Gas - Used by Germany and it is now legal in Arizona, Wyoming and California as a secondary way.
- Hanging - This is the most common method to give death penalty in the most of the countries like India, Iran, Pakistan, Japan, Malaysia and many more.
- Shooting – By a single shot like in China, Russia, India etc- or by firing squad like in Indonesia.
- Stoning – Countries like Iran, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Northern Nigeria are using this method to give death penalty.
- Decapitation – Only Saudi Arabia use this method by using a sword.
Death penalty in India
It is the capital punishment in India which can be given in the “Rarest of rare cases”[1].This doctrine of rarest of rare cases came in the landmark judgement of “Bachan Singh”[2]. Death penalty in India is with the thinking that as a consequence of a very serious offense, the criminal should get the penalty like death which is justice with the victims and their families. One more concept is that if the punishment is given to a criminal, then many other criminal minds will get scared and they will think several times before committing such grave crimes which will reduce crime rate in the society.
The concept of Death penalty in India has been evolving since the beginning and it is still evolving time by time. Prior under “Section 367(5) of CrPc [3]” the Courts have to record the reason for the act of giving punishment other than the capital punishment if, the offence could be punishable with death. This recorded reason was named as ‘Special record’. But in 1973, major changes were done in the CrPc and after that “Section 354(3) of CrPc” [4] stated that now Judges have to mention the reason of imposing death penalty (capital punishment) in their judgements.
Death Penalty Contrary to Constitution of India
It's always been a hot topic in India as according to many reports, it is contrary to Articles14,19 and 21 of Indian constitution. These Articles provide various rights to citizens and one of them is Right to life in context of which many learned says that the death penalty infringes the right to life of the offender and the Court says that these articles do not deal directly with Right to live and further the Court says that all the rights given in these articles can be reasonably restricted by the State. The conclusion is that awarding death penalty is constitutionally right but it can be given in the most serious offences like murder, rape, mutiny etc.
Ways of executing Death penalty in India:
There are two ways to give death penalty in India one of which is hanging till death which is mentioned under “Section 354(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973” [5] and the other is death by shooting which is mentioned under “Section 166 of The Army Act, 1950”[6], “Section 163 of the Air Force Act 1950”[7] and “Section 147 of Navy Act, 1957”[8]
What are the Rarest of rare cases?
The concept of “Rarest of rare cases” for giving death penalty has come along with the landmark judgement in the case of “Bachan Singh”[9]. The concept is that the death penalty can be given by the courts in the crimes which are very serious and heinous in nature. Death penalty can be given in the cases which are mentioned below:
- Being a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit a capital offence[10]
- Treason of waging war against government of India[11]
- Abetment of mutiny[12]
- For committing murder[13]
- Abetment to suicide of a minor or insane or any intoxicated person[14]
- Attempt to murder by life convict[15]
- Kidnapping for ransom[16]
- Rape and injury which causes death or leaves a woman in a persistent vegetative state[17]
- Rape of a child who is below 12 years of age[18]
- Gang rape of a child who is below 12 years of age[19]
- Repeat offenses in the context of rape[20]
- Dacoity with Murder[21]
- Offences in relation to and enemy and punishable with death[22]
- Mutiny[23]
- Desertion[24]
- Aiding or abetting an act of Sati[25]
- Drug trafficking in case of repeat offences[26]
Prominent Case Laws:
- “Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab (1980)”[27]
There was the 5 Judges bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The landmark Judgement given in this case holds an important role in retaining the death penalty as a capital punishment. In this case the question arose that, whether the death penalty is unconstitutional? The judgement of this case cleared that the rights given Under Article 19(1) of Indian constitution,1950 are not absolute. These rights are subjected and restrain obligation to a citizen that to claim their rights, they cannot infringe the rights of another citizen. The Supreme Court also made this clear that the State can impose reasonable restrictions on the rights of the citizens.
The landmark Judgement of this case gave us the doctrine of “Rarest of rare cases”. This doctrine states that death penalty can be given only in the rarest of rare cases which are very heinous or grave in nature.
- “Jagmohan Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (1973)”[28]
This is the landmark Judgement by 5 Judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In this case death penalty under “Section 302 of IPC,1860” [29] was questioned constitutionally. The issue raised was whether death penalty is violative of Article 14,19 and21 of the Indian Constitution?
The Supreme Court cleared that death penalty is not violative of Article 14,19 and 21 of Indian constitution as the rights given under these Articles do not directly deal with the “Right to live”. And all the rights can be restricted reasonably by the State for the general public interest. Death sentence cannot be held unconstitutional.
In this case Justice Krishna Iyer gave the Judgement that the death penalty is violative of Article 14,19 and 21 of Indian constitution and said that to impose death penalty there should be two conditions required which are that the death penalty must be given in the extraordinary circumstances and the special reason to impose death penalty must be written and recorded in the judgement.
CONCLUSION
In the light of all the arguments, case laws, facts, researches and provisions mentioned in this article, we can come to the conclusion that awarding death penalty in grave and heinous offences is constitutionally valid as it lays emphasis on the concept that a citizen cannot infringe another citizens’ rights. Moreover, it is also important for instilling fear in the criminal minds so that the crime rate shall decrease in the society. The law makers of various countries have wisely crafted provisions related to the punishments in the case of heinous crimes, considering the situations and the mindsets in their respective counties. Hence, it is clear that capital punishment in India is no violative to “Article 14,19 and 21 of the Indian constitution”.[31] Therefore, it can be said that the concept of “An Eye for an Eye” is operationally appropriate in the rarest of the rare cases.
REFRENCES:
- https://www.lawyerservices.in/Navy-Act-1957-SECTION-147-Form-of-sentence-of-death
- https://indiankanoon.org/doc/32729676/
- https://www.indianbarassociation.org/constitutionality-of-death-penalty/
- https://lawfoyer.in/rajendra-prasad-vs-state-of-uttar-pradesh/
- https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-2174-capital-punishment-justice-for-murder-or-murder-for-justice.html
- https://lawlex.org/lex-bulletin/case-summary-bachan-singh-vs-state-of-punjab/24029
- https://www.lawyerservices.in/Navy-Act-1957-SECTION-147-Form-of-sentence-of-death
- https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1186784/#:~:text=166.,by%20being%20shot%20to%20death.
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment
- https://portal.theedulaw.com/SingleArticle?title=whether-the-death--sentence-is-violative-of-article-21--how-the-right-to-life-and--personal-liberty-guaranteed-by-article-21-may-be-curtailed#:~:text=The%20Supreme%20Court%20of%20India,case%20of%20Bachan%20Singh%20vs.
- https://lawcirca.com/jurisprudence-of-the-death-penalty/
[1] Doctrine given in landmark judgement of Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1980, S.C 898.
[2] Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1980, S.C 898.
[3] Section 367(5) of The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
[4] Section 354(3) of The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
[5] When any person is sentenced to death, the sentence shall direct that he be hanged by the neck till he is dead.
[6] Form of sentence of death. In awarding a sentence of death a court- martial shall, in its discretion, direct that the offender shall suffer death by being hanged by the neck until he be dead, or shall suffer death by being shot to death.
[7] Form of sentence of death. In awarding a sentence of death, a court-martial shall, in its discretion, direct that the offender shall suffer death by being hanged by the neck until he be dead, or shall suffer death by being shot to death.
[8] In awarding a sentence of death, a court-martial shall in its discretion direct that the offender shall suffer death by being hanged by the neck until he be dead or shall suffer death by being shot to death.
[9] Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1980, S.C 898.
[10] Section 120B of Indian Penal Code, 1860.
[11] Section 121 of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[12] Section 132 of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[13] Section 302 of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[14] Section 305 of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[15] Section 307(2) of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[16] Section 364A of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[17] Section 376A of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[18] Section 376AB of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[19] Section 376DB of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[20] Section 376E of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[21] Section 396 of Indian Penal code, 1860.
[22] Section 34 of Army Act, 1950.
[23] Section 37 of Army Act, 1950.
[24] Section 38(1) of Army Act, 1950.
[25] Section 4 of Prevention of Sati Act, 1987.
[26] Section 31A of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985.
[27] Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1980, S.C 898.
[28] Jagmohan Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, A.I.R. 1973, S.C 947.
[29] Punishment for committing murder is mentioned under Section 302 of Indian Penal Code.
[30] Rajendra Prasad Vs State Of Uttar Pradesh 1979, SCC (3)646
[31] Constitution of India, 1950.