Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-813 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access

<strong>IDENTITY THEFT</strong>

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2023 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, <strong>IDENTITY THEFT</strong>, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2023).

Abstract

IDENTITY THEFT

Author - Kanishka Choudhary, Student at Rajasthan school of law for women

ABSTRACT

There is no universally accepted definition of identity theft or identity fraud, although it is frequently considered one of the most dangerous rising risks. Shows that identity theft is a serious issue for people, companies, and governments alike. Make it clear that identity theft is a serious issue that affects everyone, including people, businesses, and governments. Obtaining sufficient information about another individual to make purchases for them is required for identity theft. Damage to their financial resources and a drop in their credit ratings. Damage to their financial resources and a drop in their credit ratings. Identity fraud victims and their businesses may experience severe financial difficulties. For victims and their businesses, identity fraud can result in significant financial issues. With over 2 million complaints each year, identity theft has grown to be a significant problem in the United States and many other nations. Identity theft is very frequent and involves the use of phony credit cards and phony online retailers with tempting bargains.

Introduction

Without conceptual clarification, investigate the true danger posed by this occurrence. By suggesting some definitions in this piece, we hope to provide a starting place for policy and study. We suggest that what is typically termed 'identity theft' (defined as fraud or another unlawful activity where the name of an existing person is used as a target or primary tool without that person's\sconsent) is part of the broader problem of 'identity fraud'. This, in turn, is a subset of the broader word 'identity-related crime,' which we describe as any punishable activity involving an individual's identity. Identity theft is frequently regarded as one of the most serious emerging threats. However, there is no widely recognized meaning of 'identity theft' or 'identity fraud,' and it is impossible to define them.The design of contemporary payment methods allows for identity fraud. Sellers are ready to provide goods and services to buyers in the contemporary market. Providing the promise to pay is supported by information that links the customer to a particular account or credit history, strangers may trade their word for a promise to pay. To fake this connection and purchase products while charging them to another person's account, identity theft requires gathering enough information about another person. Identity fraud involves collecting information from an individual and selling it to a third party to benefit that third party. Identity fraud can take several different forms and can involve third parties that have nothing to do with the situation at all. This can cause serious financial problems for victims and businesses, especially for those who have worked hard to create a successful business and reputation. The growth of online trading is largely responsible for the rise of identity theft in the world today. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, there are over 2 million identity theft complaints yearly. That number is likely to rise as more people begin using online services such as PayPal, which has made it easier for criminals to steal money from consumers. Identity theft is not limited to the United States, however. In many other countries, it has become a major problem. Of course, anonymous data-based transactions have characterized the credit card payment system for decades. However, in recent years retail trade has become even more anonymous and more dependent on consumer data, as Internet commerce has grown and a wider range of sellers have begun to offer instant credit to consumers based on their credit reports. These changes have lowered transaction costs for consumers and merchants, but the greater reliance on data has also created new opportunities for fraud. Public awareness of identity theft as both a personal threat and a public policy issue has increased substantially. A search of articles in the Lexis-Nexis “US Newspapers” database mentioning the phrase “identity theft” yields 30 articles in 1995, almost 2,000 in 2000, and more than 12,000 articles in 2005. Credit card issuers advertise their efforts to control identity theft, and 71 percent of respondents in a recent survey said they were personally concerned about becoming identity theft victims (Mayer, 2006).Millions of people are victims of identity theft every year, often losing access to credit cards and other financial services due to the consequences of their identity theft. This means that businesses have more to worry about in terms of lost revenue and customer satisfaction. Identity theft has several negative effects on society as a whole. It can make it harder for individuals to get credit and use their finances responsibly. It can also hurt businesses by decreasing their profits and increasing the risk of lawsuits. In this post, we will look at the causes of identity theft and how it can affect people and businesses around the world. It is well known that people use other people's credit card numbers and personal information to make purchases on their accounts without paying for them. This is known as identity theft and it is very common. Millions of people are affected every year by this form of fraud. Many have been victims of identity theft as a result of using fake credit cards or online shopping websites that offer attractive deals but are fake. This is a very common form of fraud that has been around for a long time. It affects both the victim and the fraudster in the end. Poor security practices within businesses also cause identity theft. A company can encourage employees to steal valuable customer information to obtain more customers. This can be very dangerous and damaging to the company and its reputation. A business owner can also encourage employees to carry out fraudulent activities to steal customer money and avoid paying back what they have owed. This can cause major financial damage to the company and lead to massive losses. A company can also be sued by the customer if they learn about the theft and decide to take legal action against the company. This can lead to a massive lawsuit for the business and they may lose the case altogether. These are some of the most common causes of identity theft and the impact it has on society as a whole.

Identity-related Crime

Identity can be used for a variety of purposes. People can not only use someone else's or a nonexistent identity, but they can also trade or erase identities. Such phenomena can also arise by chance. It should be emphasized that these actions do not have to be illegal: there are completely legal alternatives. There are valid justifications for doing such things with IDs. Only a subgroup of what Rost, Meints, and Hansen refer to as "identity linkage reordering" is illegal. The typology established by them, in [Le06: 50-57], is illuminating since it provides a helpful beginning point to delineate the different kinds of 'bad\sthings you can do with identities'. We suggest that the word 'identity-related crime' be used as an umbrella term for this general group. This includes all criminal offenses.

TECHNIQUES

Stealing mail or rummaging through garbage ("dumpster diving"), eavesdropping on private talks in public places ("shoulder surfing"), or taking a wallet or handbag are all non-electronic ways of identity theft. Personal data can be acquired fraudulently from government agencies, and some thieves use tombstone information to take the names of the dead. Identity theft has taken on new aspects thanks to technological advancements. Small electronic devices known as "skimmers" can be used to take confidential information from debit and credit card magnetic strips. Skimmers, which can be hidden under a counter, in an apron, or inside the card readers of gas station pumps or automatic teller machines, enable criminals to duplicate cards for personal use (ATMs). The individual is then requested to "update" or "confirm" an account, inadvertently revealing private information. DNS cache poisoning and pharming methods use phony Web sites that look like genuine companies, fooling users into unknowingly giving personal information. Viruses, adware, and malware can be used to monitor computer users' actions and gain access to the information on their hard discs, and hackers can exploit security flaws in software programs to gain access to confidential data via Trojan horse apps.

LEGAL FRAMEWORK

While identity theft is a crime, it is frequently done across geographical borders, making it difficult to identify the offender. In the United States, municipal, state, and federal law enforcement organizations investigate and prosecute violations of current fraud statutes. Other nations have specific privacy and data protection legislation in place to defend against and compensate for identity theft. In Australia, for example, the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner is in charge of combating identity fraud. Personal data are protected in the United Kingdom by the Data Protection Act, which governs the correct use of personal data gathered and used by organizations…Laws protecting identity theft :Considering the long list of forms of Identity Theft, let us choose the top two of its ways, i.e., ATM Skimming and Phishing.

ATM Skimming

The concept of "cash anywhere, anytime" has promoted the installation of machines that enable approved account users to withdraw cash easily. Automated teller machines (ATMs) became the main and much-needed facility that banks offered to their various customers sooner rather than later. ATM theft has been carried out in a variety of ways for many years, including the installation of keypad overlays, hacking of cameras installed in rooms, and the installation of cameras in the machine itself. Among all of these, skimming has evolved into a much more sophisticated and worrisome type of financial fraud. Identity theft is regarded as the starting place for other types of offenses, and thus a whole sequence of events can occur.

Although no precise description of ATM skimming has been given, ATM "Skimming" is an unlawful activity that entails installing a device that is typically undetectable by ATM users and covertly captures bank account data when the user enters an ATM card into a specific machine. Criminals can use such a thorough technique to encode stolen data onto a blank ATM card and use it to take money from the account holder's bank account.

Given the severity of crimes such as ATM skimming, the appropriateness of law and accountability for such high-end sinister crimes is an issue that must be addressed while delving into the world of such offenses. The Information Technology Act of 2000, along with the Information Technology (Amendment) Act of 2008, are the only pieces of law that can deal with ATM skimming offenses to some degree.According to the court  ATMs fall under the jurisdiction of cyber penal laws because any computer system is an integral part of an ATM, and the mechanical function of cash dispensation or cash deposit is processed based on information processed by a such computer system in the respective ATM. As a result, ATMs can be deemed computers under the Information Technology Act of 2000. The latest Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019, attempted to include harm and the standard on which such scammers can be held accountable. Although the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019, does not define damage or injury specifically, it does explain "harm," which expressly includes situations causing bodily or mental injury, loss, distortion, identity theft, and financial loss or loss of property, as well as the standards on which such criminals can be penalized, which are more inclusive of the critical aspects of ATM skimming. The shortcomings in data security and corporate liability can be identified in Section 43A of the Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008, which states that any corporate entity possessing, interacting with, or managing any ‘sensitive personal data' is liable.

In the matter of Vidyawanti v/s. State Bank of India, the petitioner filed a revision appeal with the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in New Delhi. In this instance, following a failed transaction at the State Bank of India ATM located at Nehru Place, Karnal, several unauthorized transactions were made at the ATM using the complainant's account. On the same day, the accuser wrote to the State Bank of Patiala, requesting a refund of Rs. 40,000 that had been incorrectly taken from her account. However, the replies did not comply. As a result, the offended party filed a consumer report. The judge determined that, based on the information presented to the Hon'ble Court, It was obvious that a third party had tampered with the ATM, resulting in illegal activities. Because the money was unjustly taken from the complainant's account, the body corporate that was in the banking business profited from it and was obligated to compensate the aggrieved party for the loss. This case clearly outlined the extent of the bank's liability for ATM manipulation, as the weight of responsibility would be on the banks to ensure that the ATM devices were not tampered with and that they met security standards.

Phishing

According to the Oxford Dictionary, phishing is the deceptive practice of sending e-mails masquerading as reputable businesses to persuade individuals to disclose sensitive personal information such as passwords and credit card numbers, among other things. Phishing is a type of identity fraud that attempts to take private information from users such as online banking passwords, credit or debit card numbers, and other similar information. It is defined as an activity that is used to trick people into giving up their financial identity, such as bank account details, pan card numbers, account passwords, and so on, over the Internet, by e-mail, or by other means, and then using such sensitive information for fraudulent activities to defraud users.

The Indian legal system has defined "phishing" in the case of the National Union of Software and Service Businesses v/s. Ajay Sood. The judge determined that 'phishing' is a type of online fraud. In the case of phishing, a person poses as a legitimate organization, such as a bank or an insurance company, to obtain confidential data from a user, such as access codes, passwords, and so on, which he then uses to his benefit, and misrepresents the identity of the legitimate party. In general, phishing schemes involve individuals posing as representatives of online banks and siphoning funds from e-banking accounts after duping consumers into providing private banking information. Although phishing is not a new danger, the continuous improvement in assault quality makes it even more unpredictable. The advent of new dissemination methods, such as instant messaging and social networks, poses newer threats and makes phishing discovery even more difficult. Vishing, also known as 'voice phishing,' is the most recent advancement in this area. Vishing assaults are carried out over the phone. Similarly, 'Smishing' is a novel method for phishing through SMS.

From a legal standpoint, phishing is punishable in India under the Information Technology Act, of 2000, because it includes falsely acquiring private information by disguising a site as a trustworthy entity. Sections 66, 66A, and 66D of the Information Technology Act of 2000, as well as Articles 420, 379, 468, and 471 of the India Penal Code, are relevant to hacking. Section 66A of the IT Act's repealed clause (c) states that such an act is punishable if any person, using any computer resource, communication device, or electronic mail, sends a message with the intent to annoy, inconvenience, deceive, or mislead the addressee or recipient about the origin of such message. The act of phishing could have been included in this section under clause (c) because phishing is an act of deceiving and misleading the receiver of the mail, SMS, or any other electronic form, but this section was later omitted in 2015 because it violated the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(2) of the Indian Constitution. However, Section 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000, punishes deception by impersonation using any communication device or computer resource with incarceration for a period of up to three years, as well as a fine of up to one lakh rupees. This part, however, does not specify the term 'phishing,' but it is still inclusive of 'Phishing' and its expanded versions since phishing involves deception to deceive or dupe people to take data or money. While the number of phishing instances is increasing, no method or authority has been established to address these issues. The only method for victims of phishing to seek redress is to file a complaint at the police office where the crime was done. The Indian police agency is ill-equipped to deal with identity theft-related crimes due to a dearth of technology. The police agency must be able to conduct harsh actions. Each district, if not each police station, must have a cyber-cell or cyber-crime division. Even in the newly published National Cyber Security Strategy, 2013, there are only recommendations, with no real technique for reducing the rising number of identity scams.

Protection from Identity Theft

To safeguard oneself from the rising number of identity theft instances, the following precautions are suggested: Use of a strong passcode or a hidden protection PIN is required. Passwords must be changed frequently. Keeping away from dubious or suspicious webpages and connections; Never give anyone else your confidential details; Document and critical info security; Using an approved security barrier to prevent unauthorized access to electronic devices; Limiting credit card and other confidential information card vulnerability. If someone has been a victim of identity theft, it is critical to call the local police station as soon as possible, followed by a complaint at the residing area's Cyber Cell Police Station and the relevant organization, for example, If Naveen's bank details have been compromised and an unauthorized transaction has occurred, he should notify the bank officials where he is the approved account user.

CONCLUSION

Identity theft is an enormous violation of privacy that affects the victim both psychologically and socially. The effect of identity theft, however, is not confined to individuals; it also presents a threat to organizations and businesses. From a legal standpoint, Indian laws lag when it comes to the protection of identity theft, or the data of a person or group, allowing room for significant development in laws, policies, and regulations concerning identity theft. The absence of specific laws has resulted in a slew of deceptive offenses that have grown exponentially in the last two decades. A good system with an efficient hierarchy of authority is required to guarantee the sufficient implementation of current laws and to equally watch the situation. It is also essential to limit electricity overlapping and to hire sufficient humane staff. Finally, the government must raise consumer knowledge about methods to safeguard confidential information and use safe internet practices. Furthermore, they must be taught about their rights and the redressal methods accessible to them in the event of identity theft. Individuals should also keep track of their credit report and confidential data wherever it is used, and ask for justification as to why such data is being used, to minimize the damage and early discovery of identity theft.

References

  1. How to spot a "fake order" scam - Microsoft Support. (n.d). https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/topic/how-to-spot-a-fake-order-scam-e13350ca-1fa0-4e81-a452-e79aa009c4e0
  2. 5 common types of identity theft | McAfee. (n.d). https://www.mcafee.com/learn/5-common-types-of-identity-theft/
  3. Housing and accommodation have become a major problem in many countries .... (n.d). https://writing9.com/text/5fdae7278a9fbf00193d40fd-housing-and-accommodation-has-become-a-major-problem-in-many
  4. econ ch 1-5 Flashcards | Quizlet. (n.d). https://quizlet.com/421406896/econ-ch-1-5-flash-cards/
  5. Identity Theft - jstor.org. (n.d). https://www.jstor.org/stable/27648247?read-now=1
  6. Cane, P.. (2019, June 28). Communicating in Product Harm Crises: Do the Right Thing. Journal of Food Science <strong Class="highlight">and</Strong> Engineering, 9(6). https://doi.org/10.17265/2159-5828/2019.06.005
  7. 2023 Identity Theft Facts and Statistics. (n.d). https://identitytheft.org/statistics/
  8. Identity Theft - United States Department of Justice. (n.d). https://www.justice.gov/criminal-fraud/identity-theft/identity-theft-and-identity-fraud
  9. 10 Causes of Identity Theft and How to Avoid It. (n.d). https://securitygladiators.com/threat/identity-theft/cause/
  10. What Is An At Sign ( @ ) & How Do You To Use It? - Thesaurus.com. (n.d). https://www.thesaurus.com/e/grammar/at-sign/
  11.  Laws that govern ID theft in India https://blog.ipleaders.in/laws-that-govern-id-theft-in India/#:~:text=According%20to%20the%20Indian%20Law,(IT%20Act)%2C%202000.

← Back to Repository Search