<strong>Inspection Of The Legal Framework Towards Prostitution Globally.</strong>
Abstract
Inspection Of The Legal Framework Towards Prostitution Globally.
Author - Ishita Bobal, Student of Vivekananda Institute of Professional Studies- Technical Campus, Pitampura
Abstract
The status of a prostitute in a society is degraded and strict laws are very much essentials to provide them the dignity. The cases of violent attacks on the sex workers are increasing day by day and for their security the regulations are necessary. Every country has a different approach towards sex workers and countries like New Zealand are working considerably for the development of this marginalized sector as well.
Introduction
There are many people and organizations who have tried to define the practice of prostitution, it can be set to as when a female provides her body or sexual pleasures in return of someone. The immoral traffic act, 1956 defines prostitution in section 2 (f)[1] as the means of sexual exploitation or abuse of persons for commercial purpose. People of conservative view and people who are religiously very devoted consider this practice of selling sexual services immoral and undignified profession. There are many problems related to the selling of sexual activities (considered as socially immoral act). Many females are brought into this wishes circle even without their will. Some of them are too young to understand what is happening with them and what would be the consequences of it. As the world is growing, many feminists consider this act as degrading the individuality of a woman. People do believe that this type of activities also lead to pornography and also prostitutes are subject to various types of abuses which my turn into slavery. Many studies have shown that prostitution as a profession leads to human trafficking and violating the fundamental rights which are provided to the citizens. Talking of 21st century male prostitution are becoming a fashion and are called gigolo.
History
Prostitution is a concept which can be traced back to ancient times and many researchers have quoted it as that of โone of the oldest means of living of the world". The ancient[2] Vedic text rig Veda clearly mentions prostitution as the state of unmarried women and sadbrani (sadbrani are females who offer sexual pleasure for payment). Prostitutes were usually called Devdasis (Dev means God and dasi means slave) these devdasi were the slaves for the entertainment of upper class, it included dancing, enchanting, providing sexual intimacy, oral sexual pleasures. Tracing back to the time of Aryans they also had a great system of prostitution. In the Aryan era they used to have maidens. Aryans gifted the maidens to the kings of other Nations as the token of friendship and strengthen their relations. Even the notion that after leaving the worldly affairs and observing penance one can get into holy abode called swarga. It is said that if the good deeds of a person let him into Swarga after death, then the person would be enchanted by the apsaras. Even during the period of Ramayana, apsaras were there and can we call as divine prostitutes. Talking of the period of Mahabharata the kings had huge harems, concubines, etc. Even the famous textbook ARTHASHASTRA written by Kautilya have the traces where the code of conduct, rules and regulations, of prostitution are mentioned even the text mentioned how prostitutes should behave and what are their rights and duties. In the ancient times we have often heard the word โganikasโ, these are the glorified prostitutes who were trained with the seduction art and enchanting to provide pleasure to the royal court. Kings used to keep courtesans to have pleasure.
The medieval history which was mainly by the Mughal rulers had the concept of tawaiff and mujras. The Mughal rulers had great harems. The number of females in harem denotes the power of Empire.
Even during the modern history the Britishers all women except that of upper class marriages that two of Hindu monogamous relationship work considered as prostitutes, they included the dancing girls, widows, women in polygamy, women factory workers and domestic servants. The British government felt the necessity to keep attractive young women available in the cantonment area so that the British soldiers could have a reason to work in the military. Hence the British authorities critically analyzed the growing needs for the commercial sexual pleasures among the British soldiers. Even during 1864 the cantonment act allowed the working of brothels within the British military spaces to provide pleasure to European males. According to the studies during the 19th century before the implementation of contagious diseases act most of the British soldiers were suffering from veneral diseases and that was a cause which made British government look into the health of the sex workers. The British history also witnessed that Indian prostitution was one of the colonial subjects. Britishers in 1864 drafted the legislation called contagious diseases at and implemented it in India, to prevent the sexually transmitted diseases and prostitution The prostitutes were asked for the medical examination and was given a form to fill her description about her social and physical status. But on the other hand prostitutes was made available to soldiers.[3]
Causes of Prostitution
The causes of prostitution can be mainly divided into primary and secondary causes:-
The primary causes include poverty, unemployment and human trafficking whereas the secondary causes include unwilling indulgence by family and friends, rape convicts who are not accepted by the society, incests (rape by the family members).
- Poverty- India and many other countries of Southern Asia have notable poverty where people are not even having food to eat. The backward areas where even the government schemes are difficult to implement lead very poor life. People in these areas are even deprived of the basic necessities that is, food, clothing and shelter. Hence to fulfill these basic necessities females are compelled to indulge into these activities to earn a living. Poverty still remains the number one cause for prostitution in under developed and developing Nations. Studies have shown that most females who work as a sex worker comes from a poor background.
- Unemployment- unemployment itself is a social stigma where uneducated and unskilled people don't have access to the employment opportunity. These helpless people have no other option but to engage into sexual activity to make the both ends meet. The situation where poverty and unemployment are there, it automatically leads to very dangerous combination and becomes the cause of prostitution.
- Human trafficking- human trafficking still remains one of the social evil and leads to dragging a considerable number of females into the sex work. Countries of south-east Asia and other continents witnessed practices of illegal human trafficking which leads to unwilling female to get involved into the sex industries.
- Unwilling indulgence by family and friends- some females are thrown into this type of slavery and sold by their family members or by their partners. Researchers have shown that many families trade their females to get some money.
- Rape convicts who are not accepted by the society- rape is the consequence of patriarchal society where females are considered as a property and there is a society of male dominance. People tend to think that the rape convicts are impure and hence cannot live a dignified life in the social setting. They are pressurized to leave the society and discriminated which usually leads them to the way of trading themselves.
- Incests- when people indulge into sexual activities within the prohibited degrees of relationship are called incests. The near family members drag the females usually that of minors and young girls into having sexual activity with them. This lead to them involving in this oldest profession of prostitution.
Prostitution around the globe
Prostitution is dealt differently around the globe. Different countries have different policies related to this activity. Some countries like Kenya, where third party prostitution- brothels and other people who get money from prostitution is strictly not tolerated whereas they recognize it as a work and advocate the rights of a sex worker. Countries like India, France and Canada legalize prostitution as a work but employ certain limitations to it. There are countries who have codified rules and norms with which they make this sex work legal such as Austria, Netherlands, New Zealand. Talking of India specifically, India has certain provisions in Indian penal code, 1860 such as section 372 and 373[4] which talks about selling of minors for prostitution and sex work. Even the punishments are codified under section 366A, section 366B, section 370A of Indian Penal Code, 1860.
New Zealand and Sex Work[5]
New Zealand have codified rules and regulations for the sex workers in which they allow brothels, private dwellings and outdoor sexual activities.
Though, the Government of New Zealand is very lenient for prostitutes who work for themselves, in an alliance with their friends, work from their home, etc.
The health ministry of New Zealand, the business innovation and enterprise ministry, the justice system, the ministry of occupational safety and health, the ministry of immigration of New Zealand, the medical officers of health and even the police of New Zealand works for the betterment of sex workers.
In 2003, they enforced the prostitution regulatory act and clearly framed the laws for sex workers. Even this act says that the laws for sex workers are same as that of other works, the prostitutes have similar labor rights as that of a person working under an MNC, they are even provided with work place protection and healthcare. This act came to decriminalize prostitution and to provide equal rights to the sex workers and to ensure welfare, public health and to strictly prohibit the prostitution of minors. Even this act provides prostitute the right to decline the sexual intercourse without giving a reason to the client even if the payment is done. The government insures that safe sex is practiced and hence provide condoms and dental dams to decrease the risk of sexually transmitted diseases/ veneral diseases. The purpose of this act is to create a framework which clearly safeguards the human rights, avoid exploitation, providing health and safety for sex workers, to work for public health at large, to decrease the risk of human trafficking. Even the police has a significant contribution in implementing this act as this model focuses on providing remedy to justice to all the sex workers as that of any other normal citizen. Even if the local laws allow brothels or third party prostitution, then they are required to promote safe sex practices. The brothel operators have to possess a certificate to hire or set shift and other conditions for sex workers. New Zealand government appreciates and provides employment opportunities to the sex workers who want to quit this profession and like to do different work.
Prostitution in Kenya
According to the canyon penal code, third party prostitution is a criminal act where are they doesn't criminalized sex work. They have a designated alliance to work for this area, KESWA- Kenya Sex Workers Alliance. This alliance recognize sex work and provides equal protection of human rights they clearly advocate sex working rights through their awareness camps, capacities strengthening programs, organizational development camps and advocacy. Though the government of Kenya is criticized because of the increasing sex tourism on the coast of Kenya even studies have shown then it is the most HIV positive country with 30% of sex workers as HIV positive. Even human trafficking for sexual pleasures have also seen and witnessed in the country of Kenya.
India's stance on prostitution.
India's democracy is world famous and provides fundamental rights to its citizens. India believe that even the sex workers or marginalized groups are entitled to have fundamental rights. Article 21[6] of the Indian constitution provides right to life to everybody which includes the right to life of earning income which can be through sex work.
In the famous case of Baudhadev karmaskar v. State of West Bengal (1999)[7] Supreme Court of India Clearly provided the rights of sex workers and their vulnerable state and social stigmas attended to them. The Judgement came because the sex workers are mistreated and murdered and are considered as a property by the clients which become demons when they do not get what they want. The Supreme Court gave judgement that such acts are intolerant in a civilized society. And article 21 of the Indian constitution provides every individual with the right to life and that of personal liberty. Sex workers doesn't nearly have an animal existence but should also have all the rights that are provided to the normal citizens.
The immoral traffic (Prevention) act of 1956, under section-3, section-4, section-5, section-6, section-7, section-8[8] criminalize third party and brothels punishable, including kidnapping and inducing someone into sex work. This act also ensures that girls are not detained in brothels without their will. Even the rule that there should be no activities of prostitution where within the radius of 200 meters is an educational institution, hostel, temple, etc, if this happens it amounts to a punishable offence. In the case of Kajal Mukesh Singh & Ors v. State of Maharashtra (2021)[9] the Supreme Court quoted that โProstitution is not an offence, a woman has a right to choose her vocationโ
Conclusion
In most of the countries morality of prostitution is questioned. No one can trees the exact time when it started but we only have stance that this practice prevailed in ancient times. Different people have different opinions many countries even have legalized prostitution and some even have criminalized it. Some countries thing that regulation of sex activities must be done under the Ambit of government so that these sex workers get right to work without any fear and restriction. Regulations on these activities would also decline the violent cases of murder of sex workers[10]. But there are opinions that de criminalizing prostitution will lead to human trafficking, people believe that it doesn't control the sex industry but rather it expands it, it might increase the child prostitution, it doesn't clearly protect the women in prostitution, it would increase the demand of men to indulge into these activities and buying bodies for the satisfaction which will increase to a chain of socially unacceptable and morally wrong activities. It would disturb the functioning of a civilized society. But the instance that regulating the prostitution activities just like New Zealand widens the scope for sex workers and provide them a dignified life.
Refrences
- Immoral traffic act, section2(f), Acts of Parliament 1956
- Speaking Tree, (06.03.23, 7:08pm) https://www.speakingtree.in/allslides/prostitution-in-ancient-india/213372
- The Indian Prostitute as a Colonial Subject Bengal 1864-83, https://cws.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/cws/article/download/37658/34208/43579 (06.03.23, 7:12pm)
- Indian Penal Code, 1860, section 372, 373, No. 45, Acts of Parliament,1860 (India)
- The New Zealand Model, https://www.nzpc.org.nz/The-New-Zealand-Model#:~:text=Sex%20work%20is%20decriminalised%20in,of%2018%20into%20sex%20work, (06.03.23 7:32pm)
- INDIA CONSTI, art 21
- Budhadev Karmaskar vs. State of West Bengal (1999)
- Immoral Traffic (prevention) act, 1956, section-3, section-4, section-5, section-6, section-7, section-8, No. 104, Acts of Parliament, 1956 (India)
- Kajal Mukesh Singh & Ors v. State of Maharashtra (2021), (Criminal Writ Petition no. 6065 of 2019)
- Smt Afjal Begum v State of UP (2019) 07 BOM CK 0043
[1] Immoral traffic act, section2(f), Acts of Parliament 1956
[2] Speaking Tree, (06.03.23, 7:08pm) https://www.speakingtree.in/allslides/prostitution-in-ancient-india/213372
[3] The Indian Prostitute as a Colonial Subject Bengal 1864-83, https://cws.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/cws/article/download/37658/34208/43579 (06.03.23, 7:12pm)
[4] Indian Penal Code, 1860, section 372, 373, No. 45, Acts of Parliament,1860 (India)
[5]The New Zealand Model, https://www.nzpc.org.nz/The-New-Zealand-Model#:~:text=Sex%20work%20is%20decriminalised%20in,of%2018%20into%20sex%20work , (06.03.23, 7:32)
[6] INDIA CONSTI, art 21
[7] Budhadev Karmaskar vs. State of West Bengal (1999) (Criminal Appeal No. 135 of 2010)
[8] Immoral Traffic (prevention) act, 1956, section-3, section-4, section-5, section-6, section-7, section-8, No. 104, Acts of Parliament, 1956 (India)
[9] Kajal Mukesh Singh & Ors v. State of Maharashtra (2021), (Criminal Writ Petition no. 6065 of 2019)
[10] Smt Afjal Begum v State of UP (2019) 07 BOM CK 0043