Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-473 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
โœ“ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed ๐Ÿ”“ Open Access

Case comment on Agavai v. State of Tamil Nadu

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2022 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, Case comment on Agavai v. State of Tamil Nadu, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2022).

Abstract

Author - Prakhar Bajpai, Student from National Law University, Punjab.

INTRODUCTION

The present case of Agavai v. State (Govt. of Tamil Nadu)[i] was referred to the division bench of the High Court of Madras by a single bench of Justice A.D. Jagadish Chandira, to settle a question of validity as to whether the detention order under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 [ii] given by the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB) of Thiruvallur concerning the Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences, 2012[iii] (hereon referred to as POSCO act).

The present situation can be analysed as:

1] Whether or not the Juvenile Justice Board's order detaining a minor boy in an observation home under Section 18(1)(g) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015[iv] and punishing the accused under Section 5(j)(ii) [v] read with Section 6[vi] of the POSCO act is valid.

2] Whether or not, the Juvenile Justice Board, being a gender-neutral body, considered the age of both parties involved in the case, considering the fact that the petitioner is older than the accused.

3] Whether or not the petitioner's excessive delay in filing the case with the Juvenile Justice Board was taken into account

The main contention of the accused in seeking criminal revision was that the Juvenile Justice Board had issued an order that was directly contrary to the procedures laid down by the Apex Court and various High Courts to be followed in juvenile cases. It was found that it was a consensual affair between the petitioner and the victim girl. The Juvenile Justice Board is treating the statements of the petitioner as a confession without initiating a free trial, and it is being twisted as a sexual assault. Moreover, contending that the witnesses cited in the police report were not cross examined to prove the case of the victim girl.

Topics to discern:

  1. The Division bench of Madras High Court on the issue.
  2. Errors done by the Juvenile Justice Board in the present case.
  3. True Intent of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act
  4. Conclusion

THE DEVISION BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT ON THE ISSUE.

The court noted in the Para 49:

This court feels that it may not be out of context to express here that the pandemic situation had created a fickleness in the minds of people and it totally changed the human life and their attitude towards even the neighbourhood. It had not only had much impact on the financial status of the public, but, also their morality. For about two years, they had to be detained themselves inside four walls or within a short circle and after they come out of such rigid period, people with mature minds could cope up with their regular world, whereas, it appears that the teenagers face great difficulties to travel in the distorted path to achieve their goals.

Para 51:

The procedures contemplated under the Juvenile Justice Act ought to have been adopted before passing any order of detention and that too is supposed to be the last resort after making a reasonable inquiry, as specifically mentioned in subclause (xii) of Section 3 of Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015[vii]. However, in the case on hand, no such procedure appears to have been followed properly and merely by relying on the statement of the petitioner/minor alleged to have been given on his own volition and without going into its genuineness, a hazy order of detention came to be passed by the Juvenile Justice Board in a hasty manner, which certainly warrants interference.

Para 52:

In the result, the order of detention dated 17.3.2020 passed by the Juvenile Justice Board, Thiruvallur in J.C.No.21 of 2020 is set aside. The petitioner is set at liberty forthwith. Bail bond executed, if any, shall stand cancelled.

The Viayalakshmi and Others v. State Rep. the Inspector of Police and Others[viii] case was referred by the Madras High Court where it has been explicitly established fact that, the children live in the society which is the by-product of the social and biological events which are necessarily responsible for overall development of a human and the knowledge of the underlying pathways. Keeping these things in mind it is pertinent to apply the sacrosanct approach of "biosocial approach" in which these things are regarded as the mutually constitutive and biomedical behavioural models. It's only natural that cases of the aforementioned type are on the rise at the moment, and ignoring the fact that society is always growing and impacting people's identity and cognition isn't helping matters.

The POCSO Act when passed by legislature never was established on the base line to punish an adolescent boy who enters into a relationship with a minor girl by treating him as an offender. An adolescent boy or girl who is going through hormonal and biological changes and whose decision-making skill is still developing should primarily rely on their parents and society for help and direction. In Sabari @ Sabarinathan v. The Inspector of Police[ix] the court held that it is now a perpetual question mark on the face of the court as to how a relationship can be described when the girl is less than 18 years old and is in a consensual relationship with a teenage boy, even though such a relationship would be the product of mutual innocence and biological desire. The following relationship between the two must be considered natural and arises out of the hormones that make them attracted to opposite sexes. Though the natural relationship becomes complicated when entangled with the legal terms, even when the girl is under the age of 18, is mentally mature and capable of providing permission for a relationship, the terms of the POCSO Act will be invoked attracting the strong arm of law sanctioned by its rules catching up with the alleged sexual assault perpetrator, who faces a sentence of 7-10 years in prison. Referring the Kenyan Court, In P.O.O. (A minor) v. Director of Public Prosecutions & the SRM, Mbita Law Courts[x], stated that in considering whether children had the capacity to consent to sex as well as what crime was committed when such an act occurred and who ought to be charged, opined: โ€œI think these are children who need guidance and counselling rather than criminal penal sanctions.

ERRORS DONE BY THE JUVENILE JUSTICE BOARD

  • The following is Rule 19 (14) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Model Rules, 2016: At the juncture when the case is being disposed-of, there must be at least three members present, which includes the chairperson. If the chairperson is not available, the bench shall include the person who is nominated by him to act in his position. However, in the case on hand, the Board was not constituted in accordance with Rule 19(14) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Model Rules, 2016 and at the time of final disposal of the case, only one member, that is, the learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice Board, Thiruvallur, had delivered the order.
  • The Juvenile Justice Board primarily relied on the juvenile accused boy's guilty plea.

Because of the common man's incompetence, this court has emphasised that before acting simply on a guilty plea, the court must be thoroughly satisfied that the accused understood the substance of the allegation levelled against him. Considering this, the court referred to Gopal v. State Rep by The Inspector of Police[xi] and considered the relevant part of the ruling where the court believed that the court should be completely satisfied that the accused comprehended the nature of the allegation levelled against him before acting merely on the plea of guilty. A common man, more specifically, an uneducated, impoverished man from a far-flung area of the country, may not know what the offence of murder is in the context of the Penal Code, 1860[xii] is when an accused, without knowing these nuances, pleads guilty, there is a danger of conviction for him for an offence that he has not committed.

TRUE INTENT OF THE JUVENILE JUSTICE (Care and Protection of Children) ACT

Children that are entangled in the legal system rather than securing their future must be considered children in tough situations, and the juvenile justice system's approach should be geared toward resolving children's vulnerabilities and assuring their rehabilitation. In actuality, the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act of 2015 is based on reform and rehabilitation rather than punishment. The concept underlying rehabilitation is that people are not born criminals and should be given the opportunity to reintegrate into society. It also keeps them from becoming repeat offenders. Rather than punishing them as criminals, rehabilitation aims to transform a law-abiding adolescent into a productive member of society through education or treatment. The Government of India's Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 takes a holistic approach to defending children's rights by ensuring proper care, development, treatment, and reintegration of children into society.

CONCLUSION

The facts and circumstances of the case led to the decision that two youths' infatuation was given criminal colour, and one of them was sentenced. The matter would not have come to light if the immature couple had not had a disagreement on the crucial day. The petitioner/minor had taken up the disagreement with the victim girl in an intoxicated state about the paternity of the unborn child, and that was the root reason for the entire matter to come to light, according to the witness accounts. As a result, it is apparent that a teenage infatuation between a minor boy and a girl who had just passed through such a stage has devolved into an unwelcome physical connection akin to a child's play. Children are born innocent; but, for a variety of reasons, many children develop delinquent behaviours and are occasionally "in confrontation with the law." Emotional outbursts, minor thefts, substance misuse, violent or aggressive behaviour, and more serious sorts of crimes are all examples of this behaviour. These habits are frequently picked up early in life. On the other hand, parents, family members, and others who care for children may assist them in learning to deal with emotions without resorting to violence. According to studies, children absorb societal standards through deep ties with their parents and others. It acts as a deterrent to criminal tendencies. The Juvenile Justice System thinks that a juvenile offender is a product of a difficult upbringing and deserves a second chance at life. In rare circumstances, the offences may have been committed without any criminal intent. The youngster is likely oblivious to the ramifications and consequences of his behaviour. Juveniles who commit crimes are not criminals; in some circumstances, they are victims of society. The problem of child criminality, like many other societal issues, is tied to our society's flaws and misalignments.

References


[i] Ajithkumar v. State, 2022 SCC OnLine Mad 1961

[ii] The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (No.2 of 2016)

[iii] Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (No.32 of 2012)

[iv] ยง 18(1)(g) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (No.2 of 2016)

[v] ยง 5(j)(ii) of Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (No.32 of 2012)

[vii] ยง 3(xii) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015

[viii] K. Gopalakrishnan v. Karunakarann, (2006) SCC Mad 732

[ix] Kalaiselvi v. State, (2020) SCC Mad 6636

[x] P.O.O. v. Director of Public Prosecutions and others (2017) K.A.R. (Kenya)

[xi] Gopal v. State of Tamil Nadu (2005) SCC Mad 877

[xii] Indian Penal Code act, 1860 (No. 45 of 1860)

← Back to Repository Search