<strong>Case Commentary of Gadadhar Guru & Anr. VS State Of Odisha: An Inter-disciplinary Approach on the offence of Affray.</strong>
Abstract
Case Commentary of Gadadhar Guru & Anr. VS State Of Odisha: An Inter-disciplinary Approach on the offence of Affray.
Author - Surjit Raiguru, Student of Symbiosis Law School, Pune
Case Name – Gadadhar Guru & Anr. Vs. State of Odisha.
Citation – Criminal Revn. 188 of 1985.
Judges – Hon’ble Justice Mr. L. Rath. [High Court of Orissa]
[Decided on 17th April, 1989]
Facts of the Case.
- On receipt of DD 229/28, Railway Colony, Mandawali, Delhi, the officers first saw that there was an assemblage spot of public persons; after distancing the assembling of public persons, they saw that three persons, namely Anil, Inderjeet, and Naresh, were still squabbling; they detached them too.
- Even during investigation, the IO discovered that the struggle between three people happened on the verge of exploding crackers.
- Following that, the investigating officer produced rukka and had the current case lodged under Section 160 of the Indian Penal Code for disrupting the public order by battling in a public venue.
- A charge sheet was submitted against the accused following a commission of inquiry.
- Thereafter, notice was sent to the accused parties under Section 160 IPC to which they pleaded not guilty and sought trial.
Arguments on Behalf of the Prosecution.
- Now, PW1 said that the altercation actually occurred in gali, when he arrived to mediate, Sunil and Anil beat Naresh, Mahesh, and Inderjeet constantly.
- He conceded under questioning that the accused Naresh, Mahesh, and Inderjeet may not have been beating anybody at the moment of occurrence.
- During cross-examination, he acknowledged the claim that Anil and Sunil had beaten the accused Naresh and Inderjeet at the time of the incident.
- Accused Naresh claimed that on the contested day, his grandmother prevented Anil and Sunil from lighting fireworks, they got into a fight with her and his brother Mahesh and that they began hitting Mahesh.
- Prosecution, in view of the above statements, pleaded that Anil, Inderjeet and Naresh were vigorously fighting at a public place leading to serious medical injuries which had caused substantial public annoyance, so thereby must be concluded guilty[1] having had sufficient grounds of committing affray[2] under Section 159 & 160 of the Indian Penal Code.
Arguments on behalf of the Defence.
- The senior defence attorney for the defendants argued that in this instance, the defendants had been wrongfully implicated. He said that no public witness who testified in FIR No. 537/09.
- Now that the prosecution has questioned three public witnesses who are alleged to have seen the contested incident, it is clear from reading their testimonies—those of PWs. 1, 2, and 3—that none of the witnesses claimed that perhaps the accused Naresh or suspected Inderjeet started the alleged altercation in a public space.
- They (the witnesses) testified that Sunil and Anil had assaulted the accused people's relatives. Even if it is considered that the accused individuals engaged in fighting in public, it has been noted that there is no proof about the accused persons initiating the dispute.
- However, the prosecution has shown zero proof of how the claimed fighting upset the tranquillity of the community. Hence, the defence plead not guilty as in ruled by the Madras High Court[3].
Judgement.
- In summary, there are three requirements for an offence to qualify as an affray: first, there needs to be two or more people in the fight, second, it must occur in a public setting, and third, it must cause a commotion of the tranquillity in the community. Only when these conditions are met can it be considered that an offence of affray has occurred for which the perpetrators are accountable.
- Even if the learned S.D.J.M.'s judgments about a conflict between the two parties and that it took place in the village of Danda are accepted, the decision that the fight had to inevitably agitate the public and satisfy the third requirement of Section 159 of the I.P.C. could not be validated.
- In the first place, public irritation is not always a sign of public peace disruption, which is more extensive and has a broader impact. A prosecution under Section 159 of the I.P.C. requires conclusive proof that the public was thereby disturbed, which would imply FIR No. 537/09 PS Mandawali State v. Anil that the accused's actions disrupted the public's regular pace of life and thus jeopardized the neighbourhood’s peace and tranquillity. Obviously, no such proof has been shown. In this case[4],it was noted that just creating annoyance to the public does not constitute a disruption of the public peace since the two concepts are wholly unrelated.
- Secondly, there is also no concrete proof that the public has been irritated as a consequence of the battle. Due to this reason, it must be decided that the petitioners' guilt on the charge under Section 160 of the I.P.C. has not been shown, and as a result, the conviction should be overturned.
Decision.
In light of the aforementioned debate, the prosecution has failed to establish that the claimed offence of "affray" which is defined as disturbing the public peace under the IPC that actually occurred. Further, the prosecution was unable to establish the defendants' guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. As a result, the Hon'ble Judge exonerate Naresh and Inderjeet of all charges and concluded the defence not guilty of affray. Additionally, this case has laid the foundation of committing the offence of affray in the State of Odisha.
Comparative Analysis.
Affray is a crime that may be categorised as a misdemeanour or a felony[5] if two or more persons fight in public and create terror among the sovereign's subjects[6]. Fighting in a private environment or when no one else is present save those who support and abet is not considered affray[7]. A meeting for such a purpose, however, is unquestionably prohibited[8], and the participants risk being charged with an affray-related misdemeanour[9].
An aggravated sort of assault is attempting to rescue someone who has been legally imprisoned or physically disrupting and obstructing officers of justice while they are doing their duties[10]. Even when committed in front of a lower court of justice, this act is highly heinous and is severely punished in the Queen's Courts as well as in the royal yard next to those courts[11]. According to the law, argumentative, abusive, and threatening words cannot instil enough fear in others to constitute an affray offence[12]; however, an affray offense may still exist even if no physical violence is used because, in situations where the individuals involved are armed with menacing or dangerous weapons, this will inevitably lead to the development of fear in the minds of others, which is an offense under common law[13]. In the absence of direct proof or evidence, it suffices to prove an offense of affray to show that any subject of the Queen was fearful of being intimidated or terrified[14] and that the conditions were such that reasonable individuals may be scared or subjugated[15]. The offence is punishable by a fine of up to 100 rupees or by both imprisonment and fine.
Critical Analysis
Even if the definition of an affray is met, there are legal defences that may be used to have this case dropped. Depending on the circumstances, there is often factual disagreement about what occurred, or the accused may have a claim of self-defence as a defence to this charge. It must be invoked in the face of hardship or the need for self-defence[16]. If this defence is claimed, the accused's behaviour under the specific circumstances will be brought into doubt[17]. Affray is a criminal offence that may be tried before a judge and jury in a county or supreme court. This infraction has a maximum punishment of five years in jail, a fine of up to one hundred rupees, or both[18].
This offence, on the other hand, may be dealt with summarily in the Magistrates' Court if the Magistrate deems it suitable and the accused agrees to have the matter decided summarily. The seriousness of the charges will decide which Court hears the case[19]. A single affray charge is often tried in Magistrates' Court. Higher courts are more likely to examine cases of more serious violence that might lead to further charges, such as deliberately inflicting damage[20]. The circumstances of the case, as well as whether you plead guilty or not guilty, will ultimately decide which court is best suited.
A skilled affray lawyer may also raise broad defences such as misidentification or the prosecution's inability to prove all aspects of the accusation. The prosecution must show that the altercation occurred beyond a reasonable doubt[21]. There are several infractions that may result in an affray charge. As a consequence, courts may impose a range of punishments, depending on the gravity of the violation[22]. The sentencing magistrate or court will evaluate the amount of preparation required, the location of the dispute, the accused's level of participation, the duration of the incident, the use of weapons, the severity of injuries and other damage done, and the effect on victims[23].
According to current case law[24], affray is considered a collective crime by the Courts, and even if a participant's individual involvement was little, he or she may still be held liable for the potentially more serious actions of other participants. However, the perpetrator is often punished more severely than the other participants.
As offences under common law, all possible penalties, from participation in a diversion program to jail, are available. In order to advise you on the likely outcome of your penalty, a qualified affray attorney must assess the specifics of your case in relation to the legal definition of affray.
Conclusion.
As a consequence, the crime of affray is considered to be a bilateral act, which denotes that it includes two or more people actively engaging in a fight against one another in public that disrupts order. A real fight between the parties is required for the crime of affray, mere tiffs and insults do not meet this requirement. It is described in Section 159 of the IPC, while Section 160 of the IPC lays out the punishment.
[1] Mandawali State v. Anil AIR 1933 MAD 779
[2] State of Uttar Pradesh VS Sughar Singh & Ors. AIR 1978 SC 191
[3] Pushpa Vs Ravi (1954) SCC MAD 11018
[4] Podan v. State of Kerala (1962) 1 Cri LJ 339 (Ker)
[5] Regina Vs Khan [Kamran] (2018) EWCA Crim 1472
[6] Joseph Oyango Agenga Vs Attorney General 2017 SCC KEN 623
[7] Shyamlal & Ors Vs State of West Bengal 2014 SCC CAL 18039
[8] Datta Pandurag Raut Vs State of Maharashtra 2017 SCC BOM 8603
[9] Selvaraj Vs State 2005 SCC Mad 104
[10] Samendra Beura Vs Union of India and Others (2013) 14 SCC 672
[11] The Queen Vs Shodeus Clement Serverus Buthcer (2013) SCC 217
[12] Anita Thakur and Others Vs Government of Jammu and Kashmir (2016) 15 SCC 525
[13] Subhash Prabhakar Alias Padishet Patil & Others Vs Anant Manya Ambekar & Others 2016 SCC BOM 5627
[14] Button Vs DPP (1965) W.L.R 1181
[15] Narendra Pashuram Patil and Another Vs State of Maharashtra (2019) SCC BOM 1812
[16] Rafat Yar Khan and others Vs State of Maharashtra and Others (2021) SCC BOM 12400
[17] Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan Vs Union of India & Other (2018) 17 SCC 324
[18] Anuradha Bhasin Vs Union of India & Others (2020) 3 SCC 637
[19] Vinod Dua Vs Union of India & Others (2021) SCC SC 414
[20] HLA Shwe & Ors Vs State of Maharashtra (2020) SCC BOM 959
[21] M. Vijaylakshmi Vs State and Another (2018) SCC MA 4047
[22] Pankaj Vs State of Maharashtra (2021) SCC BOM 5669
[23] Shrinath Gangadhar Giram Vs State of Maharashtra 2017 SCC BOM 10118
[24] DPP v. Russell [2014] VSCA 308