Expanding upon the Reverse Onus of Proof taking the Draconian UAPA in purview
Abstract
Author - Aditya Mehrotra, Student from Symbiosis Law School, Pune.
Introduction
In the interest of national security, the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) allows the government the ability to imprison persons for arbitrary and vague grounds. Its primary objective is to enable authorities to respond to activities that endanger India's sovereignty and integrity.
Numerous countries have proposed or implemented laws addressing terrorism and other national security challenges. Nonetheless, each piece of legislation has been followed by its own set of controversies. 1987 saw the passage of TADA (Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act). It remained in existence for eight years until being abolished in May 1995, after significant criticism and charges from a number of national and international human rights groups, attorneys, and even government officials. 2002 saw the passage of the Prevention of Terrorism Act (POTA), which was repealed in 2004. In addition to these two laws, the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) of 1967 is one of the oldest anti-terrorism laws and is still in existence after undergoing several modifications. Through a 2004 modification, the majority of POTA's provisions were reincorporated into the UAPA, 1967, after its repeal.
Amendment to the UAPA
The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Amendment Act, 2019 (UAPA, 2019) was the most recent amendment, and it broadened the definition of "terrorist" under Sections 35 and 36 of Chapter VI of the Act.
It gives the Director-General of the National Investigative Agency (NIA) the authority to take property derived from the profits of terrorism under Section 25 and gives personnel at the inspector level and above the ability to handle cases under Section 43 of the Act. In addition, the Central Government established a Review Committee to "denotify" any person who has been designated as a terrorist, essentially removing any institutional channel for judicial review.
Elaborating upon the Facet of Presumption of Innocence vis - à – vis UAPA
A key element of procedural fairness in criminal law is the presumption of innocence until guilt is established. It is justified by the sociolegal ramifications of a criminal conviction. This concept serves as a safeguard against erroneous convictions and guarantees that an accused person will not be crushed by the great power and resources of the state.
The contrary norm, a presumption of guilt, places an undue burden on the accused by requiring him to establish his innocence; if he cannot, he is found guilty. Such a weight is contemplated by reverse onus clauses or reverse burdens, which replace the sacred presumption of innocence with the outrageously unjust presumption of guilt.
Reversing the burden of evidence (hanging a tacit assumption of guilt around the accused's neck like an albatross) aggravates the situation.
Arbitrary bar put by Section 43D of the UAPA – A Blatant Fissure
The practical detention time lines, the slow pace of trials in India, and a cursory examination of the legislative bar of Section 43D of the UAPA prohibit a person from being held for at least 180 days, that too without the filing of an indictment by the investigating authorities.
In instances governed by Chapters IV and V of the UAPA, the accused is denied bail if there are reasonable reasons to think that the allegations against him are prima facie genuine. This sweeping prohibition on the constitutional right of a person to seek bail means that the accused has no access to the chargesheet, the First Information Report (FIR), or any other investigation materials compiled by the investigating authorities.
Even in routine police investigations, much alone those conducted by the Special Cell, it is required under Section 207 of the Criminal Procedure Code of 1973 that a full and legible copy of the charge sheet be provided to the accused so that he may seek standard bail in a court of law.
Noting this, it must be emphasised that the validity of a reverse onus provision cannot be established just by demonstrating an internal reasonable relationship. It is inadequate protection for the accused, since a fundamental truth may contribute to show a presumptive fact, but not beyond a reasonable doubt. Therefore, an accused may be convicted despite the existence of a reasonable doubt if he is unable to meet the burden of persuasion, which contradicts the presumption of being innocent.
Section 43D(5) is contrary to all civilised principles of criminal law and the rights of the accused. It is sufficient for the accused to be prosecuted for an offence for his guilt to be inferred for the same offence. The deprivation of an accused's right to liberty according to such a method would be unjust and would not constitute due process, as required by Article 21 of the Indian Constitution.
Decoding the Judicial Interpretations – Presenting an International Perspective
In this regard, it is imperative to comment on the R vs. Oakes decision handed down by the Supreme Court of Canada, which stated:
There must be a proportionality between the means and the recognised purpose.
a. The methods must be logically related to the aim;
b. Even if rationally connected, the means should harm as few rights or freedoms as feasible; and
c. There must be proportionality between the impacts of the means and the acknowledged objective.
The classic case on the presumption of innocence is Woolmington v. D.P.P, in which Justice Sankey explained that " throughout the web of the English criminal law one golden thread is always to be seen – that it is the duty of the prosecution to prove the prisoner's guilt, subject to what I have already said regarding the insanity defence and subject also to any statutory exception."
Moreover, The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966, to which India is a party, states in Article 9.1 that no one shall be deprived of his liberty except on such grounds and in accordance with such procedure as are established by law;
Subsequently, Article 9.2 states that anyone arrested shall be informed, at the time of his arrest, of the reasons for his arrest and shall be promptly informed of any charges against him.
Decoding the Indian Judicial Interpretations on the Reverse Onus Clauses in UAPA
In V.G. Row v. State of Madras, the Supreme Court determined, in accordance with the Oakes Standard (As laid out above), that the test of reasonableness must be applied to each challenged legislation, the amount of the basic right's violation, and the purpose intended to be attained.
Therefore we can reach a conclusion that Section 43D(5) about the reversal of the burden of proof does not pass the Oakes test as it fails to meet the three fundamental requirements laid out above as it fails to show a genuine connection between fundamental fact i.e. actus reus and the presumptive fact i.e. mens rea.
In Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab, the Supreme Court affirmed that the application of Section 20(8) of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987, which was a very stringent provision for granting bail, could be justified based on the presumption that the accused's trial would occur without undue delay. In contrast to this, defendants prosecuted under UAPA often spend several years in jail as pretrial prisoners. Clearly, the majority of those accused under this Act are being treated unfairly in order to fulfil the intent of the statute.
Reverse Onus of Proof vs. Right to Self-Incrimination enshrined in the Indian Constitution
There are several elements to the right to silence:
1) One is that the burden of proving the accused's guilt is with the State or prosecution.
2) Second is that an accused is deemed innocent unless his guilt is proven.
3) Third is the accused's right against self-incrimination, which includes the right to remain quiet and the fact that he cannot be forced to incriminate himself.
There are exceptions to the general norm. An accused may be forced to submit to an inquiry by permitting his pictures to be taken, his voice to be recorded, his blood sample to be analysed, and his hair or other body material to be utilised for DNA testing, among other methods.
It is important to note that, in the case of Selvi vs. State of Karnataka, the Supreme Court reviewed the legitimacy of several procedures for acquiring evidence, such as DNA Testing etc. and found that the employment of such investigative procedures constituted testimonial coercion and infringed an accused individual's right to self-incrimination under Article 20(3) and their right to life under Article 21 enshrined in the Indian Constitution.
The Court determined that the protection against self-incrimination under Article 20(3) of the Constitution must be interpreted in light of the numerous facets of personal liberty under Article 21, including the right to a fair trial and substantive due process. It was also determined that this would apply to the accused, suspects, and witnesses, would not be limited to the courtroom, and would be applied in all circumstances where the accusation may lead to a prosecution.
The right to self-incrimination is enshrined in clause (3) of Article 20, and following the Maneka Gandhi case), Article 21 mandates a fair, just, and equitable process in criminal matters. Initial consideration must be given to the distinction between the burden of establishing an issue (known as the legal or persuasive burden of proof), which never varies, and the evidentiary burden, which may continue to vary during the trial.
The violation of this principle also compromises the accused's liberty, and once a person is prosecuted under UAPA, it becomes difficult to exonerate them from the crime, since they are imprisoned purely on the basis of the presumption of guilt.
Conclusion
Reversing the burden of evidence may have far-reaching repercussions and a debilitating impact on fundamental rights. It removes the accused's rights and leaves them with no recourse to prove their innocence. This Act need to be replaced by legislation that ensures openness and judicial scrutiny. As noted in the previous remarks, major action should be done towards police reforms, including community and religious sensitization as well as attempts to minimise the police's wide arbitrariness. Political dissent legislation should be enacted to clarify accurately what comprises and does not constitute political dissent, and those who have been wrongfully incarcerated under the UAPA for a lengthy period of time and have been proved innocent should be rewarded.