IS INDIAN MARINE INSURANCE SECTOR SUFFERING A DEFICIENCY? UNDERSTANDING THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF PROTECTION & INDEMNITY COVERAGE IN SHIPPING & EVALUATING WHETHER INDIA NEEDS ITS INDIGENOUS P&I CLUB
Abstract
IS INDIAN MARINE INSURANCE SECTOR SUFFERING A DEFICIENCY? UNDERSTANDING THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF PROTECTION & INDEMNITY COVERAGE IN SHIPPING & EVALUATING WHETHER INDIA NEEDS ITS INDIGENOUS P&I CLUB
AUTHOR - HARSH BHAGIRATH BUCH, LAW CHAMBERS OF ADVOCATE HARSH BUCH
BEST CITATION - HARSH BHAGIRATH BUCH, IS INDIAN MARINE INSURANCE SECTOR SUFFERING A DEFICIENCY? UNDERSTANDING THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF PROTECTION & INDEMNITY COVERAGE IN SHIPPING & EVALUATING WHETHER INDIA NEEDS ITS INDIGENOUS P&I CLUB, MARITIME LAW AND POLICY REVIEW, 3 (1) OF 2025, PG. 08-16, APIS โ 3920-0016 & ISSN - 2583-8008
ABSTRACT
India is witnessing an expansion in the Maritime Insurance Sector corresponding to the growth of maritime trade and shipping, which is also on a steady incline. Unfortunately, this co-relation of growth is not complemented by a sturdy marine insurance framework which not only suffers from critical lapses such as reachability, acceptability and international recognition but also inconsistent Indemnity (P&I) facilities to Indian Ship Owners and more so without a dedicated Indian P&I Club. While the absence of the Protection and Indemnity facility is a commercial and market related issue, the absence of an Indian P&I Club is owing to the fact that the Insurance Act (โActโ) until its most recent form current form did not allow the operation of mutual insurance associations, which are essential for P&I clubs[1]. This legal barrier necessitated amendments to the Act, which, while was a time-consuming process, especially given the political landscape and the need for legislative approval, left shipowners dependent on foreign clubs for liability coverage. This dependency resulted in inflated costs, regulatory constraints, and limited bargaining power, thereby affecting the competitiveness of the Indian shipping industry[2], however still, has made the Indian Shipowners plying international seas akin to international clubs. The absence of a dependable domestic P&I infrastructure has thrown Indian shipowners to risks such as financial vulnerabilities in cases of additional and unexpected calls, especially in cases of pollution liabilities, wreck removal, and crew claims, which are crucial aspects of maritime risk management[3]. The Government of India, through its Sagarmala 2030 vision and the executive and regulatory arm of the Ministry of Ports and Shipping, Directorate General of Shippingโs (DG Shipping), aims to enhance port-based development and fortify India's maritime sector[4]. However, these initiatives risk being unfulfilled idealistically without an indigenous insurance infrastructure that encompasses comprehensive and varied risk coverage and legal clarity for shipowners. In this piece, the author critically examines the legal and economic obstacles stemming from Indiaโs marine insurance infrastructure, deficiencies that are faced by insurance companies and shipowners and the author, then, advocates for policy reforms to establish that India, while being a major seafaring nation, definitely needs strong claim management and insurance underwriting facilities and an Indian P&I policy to be recognised abroad and simultaneously impress upon audiences the probability and feasibility of an India P&I Club is negligent citing lack of volume and commercial inclination per se. The marine sector insurance framework proposed by the author is with the intention to not only align India with global maritime best practices but also contribute to its aspirations of becoming a dominant player in international shipping. The authorโs proposition comes from a joint analysis of critical examination, joint analysis and extensive literature review which has helped in forming a notion that also aligns with several experts in the field.[5] KEYWORDS: Indian Marine Insurance Market, Maritime Law, Insurance Law, Protection and Indemnity of Shipowners, Ships, Risk Management, P&I Clubs, Insurance Underwriting, Claims, Settlement, Assured, H&M. Commodities, Cargo.
[1][1][1] https://indiashippingnews.com/indias-pi-club-for-coastal-shipping-likely-to-start-on-domestic-waters/
[2] Sundaram, R. (2020). *Challenges in Marine Insurance and the Absence of a Domestic P&I Club in India*. Asian Maritime Review, 28(1), 87-106.
[3] Mukherjee, P., & Chatterjee, S. (2019). *The Legal Implications of Marine Insurance in India: A Comparative Study with Global Standards*. Journal of Maritime Policy & Law, 33(4), 221-245.
[4] https://sagarmala.gov.in/sites/default/files/MIV%202030%20Report.pdf
[5] Banerjee, A. (2022). Maritime Insurance and Risk Management in India: A Critical Analysis. Indian Journal of Maritime Law, 45(2), 112-134.