LANGUAGE AND JUDICIAL DECISION MAKING – THE IMPACT OF LEGAL JARGON AND LEGAL PRECEDENT
Abstract
LANGUAGE AND JUDICIAL DECISION MAKING - THE IMPACT OF LEGAL JARGON AND LEGAL PRECEDENT
AUTHOR - ISHA SAGAR SHRIVAS, STUDENT AT SCHOOL OF LAW CHRIST (DEEMED TO BE) UNIVERSITY
BEST CITATION - ISHA SAGAR SHRIVAS, LANGUAGE AND JUDICIAL DECISION MAKING - THE IMPACT OF LEGAL JARGON AND LEGAL PRECEDENT, LEX IS US LAW JOURNAL, 4 (1) OF 2025, PG. 12-19, APIS – 3920-0004 | ISSN – 2583-9497.
ABSTRACT
"Language and Judicial Decision-Making: The Impact of Legal Jargon and Legal Precedent" is an attempt to explore the complicated interplay that seems to exist between language frameworks and legal decisions. Legal language, in any case, is characterized by rather cryptic jargon and plays a crucial role in the very formation of legal processes but is completely inaccessible to laypersons such as litigants, jurors, or the public. This paper addresses the issue of how technical language of law may shape meaning and, at times, become a fetter to justice or a tool for maintaining relations of unequal power. Lastly, word-for-word is an essential aspect of precedent in the context of law, and it describes the procedure through which former opinions that were delivered by the courts are thought to have implications on later ones. This may lead to the just application of former rules and, sometimes, impede the legislation to fulfil new social needs. In this paper, under the theme of the Indian judicial scenario, the role of the precedent in cases where legal technicality drowns simple communication and damages judicial sense is analysed. Through qualitative analyses of relevant decisions and patterns in legal language use in judicial decisions, this study attempts to trace how lawyers negotiate between the specificity required by precedent and the latitude required for justice. Further, the paper discusses whether legal language can be changed without jeopardizing the truth and coherence of legal reasoning. In general, the study discusses how language influences the outcome of legal processes and access to justice, keeping in mind those countries with more developed systems than India's.
Key words - Language, judicial, precedent, jargon, law