Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-396 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
✓ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed 🔓 Open Access

Mediation in India, the way Forward or Not

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2022 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, Mediation in India, the way Forward or Not, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2022).

Abstract

Author – Aashi Jain, Student from National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam.

Introduction

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Alternative dispute Resolution or ADR can be described as a procedure where a neutral third party, such as a mediator or an arbitrator, aids the parties to a dispute in reaching a resolution. Dispute resolution methods include arbitration and mediation. Through this procedure measures are taken so as to help in solving the disputes amongst the parties’[i].

Mediation

Mediation is a type of dispute resolution mechanism that helps in solving the disputes amongst the parties, a neutral third person helps the opponents to come to harmony through their consensus, a mediator doesn’t force a conclusion, however, only assists the parties to do the same. The mediator sits with the parties and works together with them and sometimes separately, which is also known as the private cocus, the mediator tries to bring out a solution that is sustainable, non-compulsory, non-mandatory and reasonable.

When the parties come to a conflict and decide to go for mediation, then the main role of a mediator is to create a facilitative understanding between the two parties, the mediator has to be neutral without favoring a party or championing a particular solution, it is to the parties whether they are willing to go with the solution or not.

The mediator is not a judge nor has the power to make a binding decision, his main job is to create an amicable solution that works for both the parties, and the words spoken or told remains confidential within the parties and the mediator.

Concepts and Elements of Mediation

Mediation helps in achieving a consensus amongst the disputing parties, there are certain elements of mediation that helps in making an informed decision for the dispute, such as:

Confidentiality: the discussions that takes place with the mediator and the parties is highly confidential, it is not shared with anyone else it remains within the boundaries of the mediation hall.

Voluntariness: the final decision is made according to the will of the parties, none of them are forced regarding the same.

Neutrality: the mediator is the neutral third person who has no bias regarding both the parties and the questions that are asked are also open ended favoring no one.

Flexibility: the process is an interactive one, it helps in assisting the parties so as to come to a mutual agreement without much chaos.

Creativity: the solution that is made is the most creative one and also the best one.

Finality: the settlement creates a final agreement between the parties, however, they have an option of going to the court.

Future orientation: the settlement is such which creates a decision which will last till the future discourse.

Self-determination: the settlement is voluntary and not something coerced upon the parties.

Impartiality: the mediator is impartial so as to create faith amongst the parties to share their views and opinions.

Consent

There must be a mutual consent amongst the parties to go for mediation, it is their choice whether they want to go for the same or not. However, sometimes it might also be a case that the court might direct the parties to attend the mediation.

Role of a mediator

The mediator must be a third party that is impartial, assists the parties in identifying intrinsic issues in the problems cited and helps in visualizing their interests. The mediator must be a facilitator so that a dialogue and a solution can be created and should also be non-judgmental.

He should be impartial, and shouldn’t be inclined towards one party and if found then he should be replaced with another mediator, also there should be no conflict of interest.

Code of conduct: the mediator must follow all the rules and regulations and shouldn’t be involved in any unethical activity, shouldn’t indulge in anything which is outside the purview of the case.

Stages of Mediation

Opening Statement: once everyone enters the mediation hall, and are present the mediator explains the goals, objectives of the session and encourages everyone to talk about their problems.

Joint Discussions: after the opening statement is complete, the mediator should ask the disputants to discuss their problems and can ask open-ended questions so as to develop a dialogue, and the focus should be on both the parties.

Private Discussions: once the group discussions are done, the mediator can then have a private conversation with the parties so as to get a detailed analysis of the problem at hand.

Negotiation: once all sorts of conversations are done the mediator can then bring both the parties together so that they can negotiate their terms and conditions.

Settlement: this is the last step in the process, even if the mediator cannot settle the same then also he can assist the disputants to try again or to take the matter to trial, and if there is a settlement then it should be in writing[ii].

Why Mediation?

In the world we live in, time and money are those factors which a man strives for, and because of competition, hatred we do indulge in conflicts and hence need someone to adjudicate our matter, mediation in this case plays an important role because it is less time taking, and less expensive, also the parties have an option of going back to the court for litigation, if they are not satisfied with the decision taken, hence some sort of autonomy is present and they have a right to come to a solution that is favorable to both. The resolution of a court case may take months or even years. And the more time it takes, the more money you spend on attorneys, which is not feasible both in terms of time and money. Hence, the business organizations or individuals so as to avoid such expenses and to save time hire the services of the trained and certified mediators[iii].  

Through Mediation, the parties can understand the issues of the other party, and hence share a glimpse of what is actually taking place on the other side, which is not present in a court proceeding, also the communication that takes place in the mediation center cannot be presented as evidence in the court, if the party takes the matter to the court, hence, a high level of confidentiality is maintained.

Is it enforceable?

Though, through mediation parties can reach to a mutual decision, also the person or the mediator who assist the same is neutral and impartial, but still there exists no law that regulates mediation and there is no provision saying that the settlement is made is binding, it is hence non-binding upon the parties, which also means that even if the parties have agreed to go to the mediation as an alternate to the court proceedings they are however not forced to attend all the meetings, they can leave the mediation process even after the first meeting.

Also, even after mediation, disputes are usually brought before the courts, wasting valuable mediation time without producing any results.

The way forward

Mediation helps in relooking at the mutual interests and rights of the parties and hence come up with innovative solutions, which helps in creating a cordial relation amongst the parties.

Though the decisions in mediation are non-binding on the parties, however, they do create a future orientation of the settlement done, also as recommended by ex-Chief Justice of India SA Bobde, he says that there should be a law to ensure that all the decisions made in the mediation proceedings are binding, this will in fact help in reducing the backlog of cases pending in the court and also save the time of courts[iv].

Steps to reform and promote such processes won't be successful until the perception that mediation is a second-tier possibility changes. Mediation as a process is quite effectual and can be the way forward in solving the disputes of the parties, however, an essential aspect is to form a law that can help in implementing the same, also to have binding decision so that the problems don’t go back to the court.


[i] What is Alternative Dispute Resolution? Harvard Law School, Daily Blog.

[ii] Five stages of mediation, Breakthrough Mediation, 2022.

[iii] Jakob Vinther, Thomas Todd Reynolds, “The History of mediation”, Mediate.com, 2021. 

[iv]Murali Krishnan, The Hindustan Times, Feb 09, 2020.

← Back to Repository Search