Central Organization Institute of Legal Education (ILE) • Master Scholarly Repository & Academic Law Journals
Institute of Legal Education

Institute of Legal Education

Premier Scholarly Publishing House, Central Legal Research Repository & Academic Network
Home › Repository › Article Details
ILE-AIT-142 Indian Journal of Legal Review (IJLR)
βœ“ Double-Blind Peer Reviewed πŸ”“ Open Access

MEDICO-LEGAL ISSUES ADMIST THE PANDEMIC

Author(s): ILE Legal Blog
Volume: 4 Issue: 2 Year: 2022 ISSN: 2583-2344 APIS: 3920-0001 Publisher: Institute of Legal Education (ILE)
Recommended Bluebook Citation
ILE Legal Blog, MEDICO-LEGAL ISSUES ADMIST THE PANDEMIC, 4 Indian Journal of Legal Review 2 (2022).

Abstract

Author - SANYA KAPOOR, Student at BENNET UNIVERSITY, NOIDA

INTRODUCTION

The country has been severely affected by the second wave of Covid-19, which is undoubtedly fiercer than the first wave in 2020. Besides the detrimental effect on our health, it can also significantly deplete our finances and hurl all of our financial plans into disarray. On one side of the coin, where the medical care industry has been witnessing unprecedented hurdles, on the other side the medical billing management has encountered its own set of challenges. The pandemic has resulted in widespread unemployment and financial insecurity, which has had a direct impact throughout the medical billing and healthcare payment systems. With the spread of the pandemic across the country, though the health and safety of the patients is the foremost priority in the medical care system, but it has exposed them with an exorbitant and an erratic billing. 

MEDICO-LEGAL ISSUES AMIDST THE PANDEMIC

The combat against Covid-19 has exhibited the loopholes in the armory of our healthcare system. On one hand, there is the failing public health system, which is frantically attempting to conceal its inadequacies while dealing with the deadly global pandemic, on the other hand the private health industry has mostly steered out of the fight against the deadly virus. In the plight of the pandemic, people are being subjected to the discriminatory practices. Though fighting this illness has demonstrated the fortitude of our white-coated warriors and their unwavering dedication to facilitating and curing the illness, but the costly medical plans for the treatment at the hospitals has brought the insensitive treatment of the private hospitals. 

MALEVOLENCE OF THE PRIVATE HOSPITALS

In one of the incidents, a Guwahati based businessman after scouting several hospitals in the city was finally admitted to a private hospital. After ten days, the hospital after quoting a sum of 1.7 lakh charged almost double the amount after their discharge.[1] Across the country, though many have successfully conquered the virus, but their lives have been irrevocably changed by the massive Covid-19 medical bills and the loans they have to return. People have depleted their savings, mortgaged their property and sold their jewelry, forcing the families to the verge of destitution. The Covid 19 treatment has led to conflicts between the hospitals and the insurers, as the policyholders across the country are receiving only 50-55 percent of their actual claim value for the Covid-19 hospitalization.[2] During the global pandemic, the policyholders have been compelled to pay a significant portion of their premiums out of pocket, as the hospitals and the insurers have sparred over the high and unreasonable charges. 

In one of the incidents in Patna, the private hospital was not ready to hand over the patient to the family, after the patient had tested negative for the virus. It was only when the family had deposited an amount of Rs.13,000 the patient was given back to the family. Several state governments have been taking strict actions to combat such exploiting activities. Following the incident in Patna, the Bihar Government had declared that strict action would be taken against hospitals for exploiting common people in the guise of Covid-19 treatment, and the prices for the patient treatment should be fixed and had ordered to advertise the charges. The Government of Punjab stated that any hospital overcharging the people for the treatment will be forced to shut down.[3]The Government of Maharashtra had issued a notification to fix the cost of treatment of the Covid-19 patients at the private hospitals after receiving several complaints from the public. Even though the private hospitals have been sanctioned and several states have a put a cap on the prices for the Covid treatment, the reality on the ground is quite different. Though Article 14 had embodied the principle of equality which denotes equal healthcare for all, however, in the midst of the ongoing pandemic, these principles have gone astray resulting in a scenario in which the wealthy and the socially affluent would survive.

A RAY OF HOPE 

The faith of the public in the government and the state machinery has been undermined due to the mismanagement and the narrow outlook of the administration. The Hon’ble Court in Re: The Proper Treatment of Covid-19 Patients and Dignified Handling of Dead Bodies in Hospitals etc.[4] laid down that Right to health is a fundamental right which is guaranteed under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. Therefore, it is the responsibility of the state government and the local government to ensure provisions for economical healthcare, and furthermore, there shall be a cap on the costs which are being charged by the private hospitals, as stipulated by the Disaster Management Act. Furthermore, the Hon’ble Court in State of Punjab & Ors v. Ram Lubhaya Bagga[5] held that if a private hospital has imposed exorbitant prices in a scenario where there has been no regulated pricing, the state would be obligated to reimburse the money. Therefore, from the above-mentioned judgements, it is indisputable that Article 21 encompasses the right to health, which includes affordable treatment. In light of the above judgements a public interest litigation has been filed in the court of law[6], seeking to formulate a fresh policy regulating the cost of admission and treatment of Covid-19 patients in the private hospitals as well as mandating them to publish the rates either online or in the prominent locations inside the hospitals. Therefore, it is only the court which can function as a catalyst by reminding the government of its responsibilities and instructing the government to fix the rate of the private hospital, as this will reassure the public and urge them to keep faith in the system.[7]

CONCLUSION

To prevent the effects of the global pandemic from wreaking havoc on the fragile healthcare system, the states should be proactive in ensuring that the hospitals adhere to the policy that has been established for the treatment of the patients, and that accurate data on the vacancy of beds is published on the websites on a daily basis so that people are not forced to run from pillar to post. The Clinical Establishments ( Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010 which has been implemented in 14 states, should be implemented throughout the country and its stringent execution can assist to prevent the latches in the healthcare system.[8] Furthermore, the government should reduce the rate of GST on the Covid related supplies. The Ministry of Health of the Government of India’s Management Protocol Covid-19 outlines the adequate and the reasonable care that every medical establishment must provide for the treatment of Covid-19. It outlines the risk factors, severity of pandemic as well as the diagnostic, preventive, control procedures and repercussions that healthcare institutions and officials must bear in mind as they fight the deadly virus. Furthermore, the Central and the State Governments have the jurisdiction to establish and regulate legislation in the assessment of the standards of the facility under Section 52 of the Act. The Disaster Management Act, 2005 lays down that the right to health and the guarantee of proper treatment and services are the responsibility of the government and state, and the grievances of the public should be addressed. Section 25 of the Act establishes a disaster management authority at the national, state and district levels to address the challenges and complexities that may arise in the event of a disaster or a tragedy. Thus, as the country fights the pandemic, it is critical that we not only stay safe and healthy, but also battle against the unjust practices and the injustice to which people are being subjected to. 

REFERENCE 

[1]Rahul V. Pisharody, Janardhan Koushik, Jimmy Levion, Tora Agarwala: Mortgaging property, selling jewellery, drawing loans: how high Covid-19 bills are pushing families to the brink of penury, How high Covid-19 bills are pushing families to the brink of penury (indianexpress.com). 

[2]K.Shiva Shanker, Insurance a strict no for some private hospitals, Insurance a strict no for some private hospitals - The Hindu.

[3]Private hospitals overcharging Covid patients won’t be spared: Punjab health minister, https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ludhiana/private-hospitals-overcharging-covid-patients-wont-be-spared-punjab-health-minister-7319223/.

[4]Re: The Proper Treatment of Covid-19 Patients and Dignified Handling of Dead Bodies in Hospitals etc., Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 7 Of 2020. 

[5] State of Punjab & Ors v. Ram Lubhaya Bagga , AIR 1998 SC 117. 

[6] S. Jimraj Milton v Union of India and Others, W.P.Nos.7414 & 7456 of 2020. 

[7]Fix rates for Covid-19 treatment in private hospitals : PIL in Delhi HC, Fix rates for Covid-19 treatment in private hospitals: PIL in Delhi HC (livemint.com). 

[8] Manoj K. Singh, Health Ministry Proposes Clinical Establishment (3rd Amendment Rules), 2019,Health Ministry Proposes Clinical Establishment (3rd Amendment Rules), 2019 - Food, Drugs, Healthcare, Life Sciences - India (mondaq.com).

← Back to Repository Search