NATIONAL SECURITY GROUND TO CURB FREE SPEECH: AN ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
Abstract
Author - Pranav Pathak, Student from Hidayatullah National Law University, Raipur
Introduction: A New Normal
The ban on MediaOne TV channel triggered the issue of freedom of press in the legal globe. Putting the long story short, the Kerala High Court upheld the telecast ban on the MediaOne News Channel in the light of national security issues.[i] The citation of national security seems like a new normal for the government to slip through the cracks. There exists a string of cases in the recent past when the argument of national security has been invoked to clip the wings of the judiciary. The case of MediaOne Channel Ban joins the club along with the Rafale case, the Kashmir Internet Ban case, the Bhima Koregaon case, and the Rohingya Refugees case, where the ground of national security has been invoked in the recent past. The argument of national security seems like an easy picking for the Government to escape from accountability. However, this raises deeply troubling questions.
National Security as a Ground: Pandora’s Box
National Security as a ground to limit the fundamental rights is invoked by the virtue of Art 19(2). Moreover, it is settled that the matter of national security is a question of policy rather than a question of law. However, the argument of national security to curb the freedom of speech and expression is a hot potato by the virtue of threefold reasons namely; restricted judicial review, infringement of “Right to Know” and exclusion of principles of natural justice.
Ill-Equipped Judiciary to Review the National Security Ground: Soft as a Grape
Democracy abhors absolutism. Therefore, judicial review seems sine qua non in a democratic sphere.[ii] However, the extent of judicial review is as clear as mud when it comes to invocation of national security as a ground for curtailment. The judiciary shifts its outlook to meet the dynamics of the society. Evidently, the judiciary gave enough rope to administrative authorities in the case of State of Karnataka v. Dr. Praveen Bhai Thogadia, where the court showed reluctance from interfering in matters where the fundamental rights are restricted in the light of S. 144, CrPC. However, the judiciary seems more penetrative when the argument of national security is invoked in the recent past. The case of Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India is a strong proponent of judicial review in infringement of fundamental rights. Considering the gravity of fundamental rights, the court insisted upon sufficient objective materials to curb the fundamental rights, and the order should be amenable to judicial review. The court explicitly insisted upon procedural justice in such cases. Similarly, the case of Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union of India is another strong proponent of judicial review in such cases. The court nodded the access of information for protecting national security but ought to be evidence based. The State does not get a free pass every time when the argument of national security is raised. Putting reliance on the case of Ram Jethmalani v. Union of India, the court explicitly opined that the state is not at all expected to take “adversarial position” when the fundamental rights are at stake.
However, there is a clear reluctance on the part of the government to reveal the information of national security importance, considering it is a matter of policy and highly confidential. Consequently, there is limited access to the comprehensive information that makes the judiciary ill-equipped to deal with the issue more efficiently. Additionally, considering that the matter of national security is a question of policy, the judiciary finds its role very limited. This renders the judicial review restricted inside the box. Therefore, the extent of judicial review is still a grey area.
- No to Right to Know: National Security Ground resides in Darkness
Democracy dies in darkness. It is the Preamble along with Art 19(1) and Art 21 that advocates the idea of open governance.[iii] Public is the owner of the information in the public sphere and the government is just a trustee.[iv] Therefore, Right to Know is sine qua non for any participatory democracy. Above all, Right to Know was rendered the status of fundamental rights under the ambit of Art 19(1)(a) in S.P. Gupta v. Union of India.
Furthermore, the Ram Jethmalani case is a strong proponent of the right to know. It was held that the denial of information to the petitioner would be to thwart the right granted by Art 32(1) unless it is constitutionally permitted. It was explicitly opined that the denial of information would render the court and petitioner handicapped in the proceedings for rendering complete justice. The state cannot be an adversary. This outlook was reiterated in Manohar Lal Sharma case.
Interestingly, the “Right to Know” seems to go in one ear and out the other when it comes to national security as a ground for the curtailment of fundamental right. In such cases, the concerned parties are not informed about the information relying upon which the decision of curtailment of right to speech and expression has been made. This is evident from the Ex-Armymen’s Protection Services Pvt Ltd case. Accordingly, the MediaOne has kept in dark about the information upon which the decision is made. Thus, the decision of curtailment resides under a dark cloud when the concerned parties are not informed about the information relying upon which the decision has been made.
The only solution in the current scenario in this regard is sealed cover doctrine, and to exchange confidential information between the State and the court in a sealed cover. Despite the fact that the doctrine is on a bandwagon in the current scenario, it is highly questionable in the democratic sphere as the doctrine leaves the affected party bereft of information that is submitted to the bench. After all, “Justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done.”
- Principles of Natural Justice: Hang by a Thread
The golden thread of natural justice gets warranted by the virtue of the Preamble, Art 14 and 21 of the Constitution. The golden thread of natural justice is the product of judicial activism. There exists a string of judicial pronouncements to bolster the idea. Despite the fact that the exclusion of principles of natural justice is a bitter pill to swallow, it is excluded in the cases of national security. In the case of Ex-Armymen’s Protection Services Pvt Ltd v. Union of India, it was held that a party cannot insist on the strict observance of the principles of natural justice when it comes to the situation of national security. The outlook was reiterated in the case of Digi Cable Network (India) Pvt Ltd v. Union of India. The similar viewpoint was opined in the MediaOne ban case. Therefore, the affected party doesn’t get the minimal opportunity to represent itself in the argument of national security, and makes the entire proceeding ex parte.
Conclusion & Suggestions: A Fight Against Executive Lynching
Regrettably India has been in really bad shape in the World Press Freedom Index of 2021. We have been placed at the 142nd rank out of 180 countries. We, being the largest democracy, need to lie back and think of our press freedom policy. The faith in democracy dwindles in the absence of transparency and openness in the governing system. The national security ground is wide enough to encompass everything under the sun. However, law has to be predictable in nature. Therefore, predictability has to be brought in the invocation of national security as a ground to curb the fundamental rights. The national security as a ground mandatorily needs a sub classification on the basis of degree of seriousness, and needs to be determined on a case-to-case basis. Furthermore, the restriction is required to be tailored in accordance with the degree of seriousness in the light of the test of proportionality. Further, the doctrine of separation of power has to be given due regard. Allowing the state to use national security as a justification for restricting rights without any safeguards can have severe repercussions. Therefore, the decisions of the government should be amenable to judicial review even when it comes to matters of national security. Free flow of information is indispensable in democracy. Thus, the Judiciary has to be well equipped with information to fight against executive lynching. Additionally, a minimum degree of principles of natural justice is sine qua non in a rule of law. Therefore, blinding the affected party without giving an opportunity to represent itself needs a far deeper consideration. In New York Times v. United States,[v] Douglas J observed, “Secrecy in government is fundamentally anti-democratic, perpetuating bureaucratic errors.” By and large, freedom of speech and expression cannot be put into a cage merely in the garb of national security. A healthy democracy resides in an open environment having proper disinfectant sunlight.
[i] Madhyamam Broadcasting Ltd v Union of India, WP (C) Nos 3265, 3663 and 3670 of 2022
[ii] MP Jain, Indian Constitutional Law (7th Ed., Lexis Nexis 2014) 19
[iii] IP Massey, Administrative Law (9th Ed., EBC 2018) 568
[iv] Id., 569
[v] New York Times v United States, 29 L Ed 2d 822: 403 US 713 (1971)