<strong>Prostitution – A Legal Analysis</strong>
Abstract
Prostitution – A Legal Analysis
Author - IRENE MARIA SHAJAN, Student at GOVERNMENT LAW COLLEGE, COIMBATORE
Abstract
I would like to start my article with an introduction of definition for the word prostitution. Cause of prostitution in India. Types of prostitution. The prostitution in the economic aspect. Ill effects of prostitution in the society. Prevention of prostitution legal provisions. Some cases related to prostitution. Conclusion.
- Introduction
The practice of engaging in relatively indiscriminate sexual activity in general with someone who is not spouse or friend in exchange of immediate payment in money or other valuables. the actor practice of engaging in premises sexual relationship especially 4 money. there are a lot of road prostitutes in and around the world. we think that there are only female prostitutes but there are Neil prostitutes also. they are called gigolo.
- Causes of prostitution in India
The main reason for the prostitution in India can be divided as socio economic factors, psychological factors, cultural factors, professional courses, and other causes.
A) socio economic cause
• poverty
• industrialisation
• Urbanization
• Lack of family values
• late marriage
• ambitious lifestyle
• !human trafficking
• abandonment
• death of parents
• Infidelity
B) Psychological factors
• Lack of confidence
• Curiosity of curiosity force sex
• mental incompetency
• ignorance
C) Cultural factors
• polygamy
• polyandry
• restriction on widow remarriage
D) Professional Causes
• Shift duties
• Distant living from family
• Regular contacts between employees
E) Other causes
• Loneliness
• Immortality
• Exploitation
• Exploitation of women
These are some of the major courses for the existence of the profession called prostitution. The prostitution is treated as a profession in India by the Supreme Court. It gives a lot of income to the economy.
- Types of Prostitutes
There are mostly four types of prostitutes around us. They are mostly called as call girls Devadasi hereditary profession of the family and gigolo.
The girl and girls are the type of prostitutes who believes that having sex gives money and fun they are the upper middle class people mostly seen in farm house luxury hotels exc.
Devadasi is nothing but they are the women who are given to the temple for the God. They are taken for the dancing and singing in those days but now they are very less in number they were the maiden who is a spinster for the life long.
Hereditary profession of the family still now some of the tribes and castes do the sexual favour for others only because they are their ancestors has done those times.
Devadasi is nothing but the male sex worker now a days they have good demand in the market. A lot of buyers are there for this crap and their it is done Profitable business.
- Ill Effects of the Prostitution
Prostitution leads to problems relating to individual, family and social disorganisation. It undermines individual character and social Morality. It is the major social problem in modern society. It poses a serious threat to the values of family and marriage. It leads to corruption in the government and police Officials. Its impact on the problems like crime, suicide, divorce and alcoholism cannot be underestimated. Prostitution and indiscriminate sex lead to venereal diseases and AIDS. It effects the health of individuals which continue for several generations. Children born of patents having venereal diseases suffer from blindness, dead and dumb, feeble mindedness, T.B.
- Legal Measures Taken
Sex education is given to the students when they reach the adolescent age. Employment opportunities are increased to improve the standard of living. Better educational facilities is given to the standard coaching. The abolishing certain social customs-Dowry, restrictions on widow remarriage is done. Public awareness about evil effects of prostitution is given widely.
The legal measures like Prevention of Prostitution Act, 1923. Sex offences under this Act were: (1) Living on the earnings of prostitution of another. (2) Soliciting in public place, Suppression of Immoral Traffic Act, 1956, Procuring and managing a brothel, UP Naik Girls Protection Act, 1929, Madras Devadasi Act, 1974, The Bombay Devadasi Protection Act, 1934 came to effect.
- Some Related Case laws
- Meenakshi And Three Ors. Vs Muniandi Panikkan And Anr. On 26 August, 1914[1]
The earliest case to which our attention baa been drawn is Tara Munnie Dossea v. Motee Buneanee 7 Sud. Diw. Adalat Reports, 273, In that case, the opinion of the pandits was that prostitution severed the in of kinship. Acting upon this vyavasta, the Sunder Court held that the daughters who were born after the mother’s fallen state and “who lived with the outcast mother and had all things in common with her,” should be preferred to the legitimate daughter. This opinion of the pandits is no longer law and a decision based upon Buck an opinion cannot he regarded as an authority. In Mayna Bai v. Vttaram (1864) 2 M.H.C.R., 196, there was no competition between legitimate and illegitimate children. Both the contending parties were illegitimate. The learned Judges accepted the dictum of the pandits in Taramonee’s case Tara, Munnee Dossea v. Motee Buneanee 7 Sud. Diw. Adalat Reports, 272 as good law and decided that in the absence of preferential heirs they inherited the mother’s property and to one another. This decision does not affect the present case. It may, however, be pointed out that the opinion of the Judicial Committee in this very case Myna Boyee v. Oottaram (1861) 8 M.I.A., 400 at p. 425 is more qualified regarding rights of succession to the mother’s property than the conclusion of the learned Judges of the High Court. Subbaraya Pillai v. Ramasami Pillai (1900) I.L.R., 23 Mad., 171, expressly laid down that prostitution did not sever the pre-existing legal relation, and dissenting from the dicta contained in the earlier cases decided that a step son was entitled to succeed. In Annayan v. Chinnan (1910) I.L.R., 33 Mad., 366, the learned Judges held that an illegitimate son by a Sudra widow whose re-marriage is forbidden had no right of inheritance. This is a distinct pronouncement in favour of the position that Hindu Law does not recognise the rights of illegitimate offspring be succeed to their parents’ property. Much reliance was placed on the recent case-Narumayya Chetti v. Tiruvengadathan Chetti (1918) 24 M.L.J., 223-on behalf of the appellant. The actual decision in that case was that the daughter of the daughter of a prostitute born to her in wedlock is to be preferred to the sons she begot after she became a prostitute. That opinion is in entire accordance with the conclusion at which I have arrived in this case. The statement that the illegitimate sons are entitled to succeed to their mother may be reconcilable on the ground that in the absence of preferential heirs and if the Crown does not intervene, they would succeed as blood relations. As I said before, the actual decision supports my view. In Bhikya v. Babu (1908) I.L.R., 32 Bom., 562, it was held that in regard to ordinary property the divided brother’s son excluded the illegitimate daughter. I fully agree with the opinion of Chandavarkar, J., in Jagannath Raghunath v. Narayan (1910) I.L.R., 34 Bom., 553 at p. 559, that there is no authority whatever in the Hindu Law for the proposition which is contended for by Mr. Pradhan, that, whan the competition is between the husband and a son born of the woman by adulterous intercourse, that son supersedes the husband as heir to the sridhanam.” A Fall Bench of the Calcutta High Court reviewed all the earlier authorities on the subject in Hiralal Singha v. Tripura Charan Roy (1913) I.L.R., 40 Calc., 650, and arrived at the conclusion that prostitution did not sever the of blood previously existing. It is true there are cases in that High Court which seem to lay down that illegitimate children have rights of inheritance. This view may be traced to the prevailing theory in Bengal that the offering of oblations has to be taken into account in determining heirship. This principle does not affect those governed by Mitakshara, and consequently these rulings are not binding on us.BB
- B.K. Adarsh vs Union Of India And Others on 6 September, 1989[2]
The third session deals with the evils of prostitution and the circumstances under which girls are driven to brothel houses. The Doctor explains with anguish the pathetic situations with an exhortation to curb it. The sale of a girl in succession starting from the father to the ultimate brothel house is only a painful social evil prevalent in the society and. We read regularly with distress of similar news in papers. There is nothing repulsive to social sensibility in that regard. The entire episode has to be understood in the background of the prevailing social evils leading to prostitution. Neither the script writer nor the producer glorifies the prostitution. On the other hand, it intends to condemn the institution of prostitution and its evil effects followed and shown in the third session relating to Veneral diseases. Thereby I find nothing repulsive in the protrayal of scenes relating to prostitution. In K. A. Abbas case (supra), the Supreme Court upheld the film protraying the flesh trade. In fact it would serve the constitutional goal set down in Art. 23 of the Constituion.
- V. Subramania Iyer vs Rathnavelu Chetty And Ors. On 4 May, 1917[3]
Even assuming that the order of succession to a sonless Hindu given by Manu and Yajnavalkya and propounded by Vignaneswara in Chapter II, Section 1, pl. 2 of the Mitakshara would not in terms apply owing to the word ‘ pita ‘ being confined to the legitimate father, and to the want of sapinda relationship between a Sudra and dasi-putra, I see nothing to prevent succession to the illegitimate son being traced by analogy to the rule laid down in verses 135 and 136 of Yajnavalkya as explained in Chapter II, Section 1, pl. 2 of the Mitakshara especially as the Hindu Law recognises heritable blood between a Sudra and his dasi-putra and Manu states that the father of every one of the classes of sons enumerated by him succeeds to the property of the heirless son. The whole law of succession to dancing girls and prostitutes in cases not expressly provided for by the rules relating to Streedhana has been built up by Courts on analogies furnished by other parts of the Hindu Law. In Kamakshi v. Nagarathnam (1868) 5 M.H.C.R. 161, Scotland, C.J. and Collet, T. held that in the absence of any positive rule relating to the particular kind of property in dispute (the hereditary office of dancing girls attached to a temple) the law to be applied is the general law of inheritance regarding daughters or sons. In Subra-mania Mudali v. Balakrishna Naidu (1917) 33 M.L.J. 207, Abdur Rahim and Sreenivasa Aiyangar, JJ.
In dealing with the question of heirship to a dancing girl whose grand-mother was the issue of a marriage between her parents observed as follows: “The rules of Streedhana obviously do not apply to such property and there is no other rule of succession laid down in the Smritis or the commentaries prescribing the devolution of property of a woman of this caste, except it be the general rule that to the nearest sapinda the inheritance next belongs.” They acted on analogies and held that the great grand-father’s brother’s daughter succeeded in preference to her great grandfather’s daughter’s son. The argument that the analogy afforded by sapinda relationship cannot be applied as there was no marriage is met by the observations that according to Vignaneswara sapinda merely connotes relationship and reference is made to the Acharadhyaya of the Mitakshara, (the commentary of Vignaneswara on verse 52). In Venku v. Mahalinga (1888) I.L.R. 11 M. 391. Muthuswami Aiyar, J. was of opinion that in the case of adoptions by dancing girls questions as to inheritance and collateral succession should be adjudicated upon in the absence of a positive rule of law to the contrary with reference to the custom of the caste and the analogies of Hindu Law as indicated in Kamakshi v. Nagarathnam (1868) 5 M.H.C.R. 161. In Ramalinga Moopan v. Pavadai Goundan (1902) I.L.R. 25 M. 519 at p. 524, Bhashyam Aiyangar, J. rested the right of representation of the legitimate son of an illegitimate Sudra on the analogy of legitimate sons and grandsons and observed: “The principles, therefore, applicable to the succession of sons and grand-sons of legitimate sons may by analogy be applied to the sons and grand-sons of an illegitimate son, viz., that they should be considered capable of representing the illegitimate son and in case he dies before his father, of taking the share which would have fallen to Trim if he had not so died.” Though there are no texts in the Smritis expressly recognising the right of an adopted son to inherit to his adoptive mother’s relations Courts have enforced the right on general principles of equity and good conscience and analogy to the right of the aurasa. The principle of atidesa whereby principles laid down with reference to one case are applied to other analogous eases was recognised by Jaimini in his Mimamsa. (Books VII and VIII of Jaimini’s Mimamsa).
- Conclusion
Prostitution is a profession which brings the income to the economy. Just consider it as a physical labour. They are also working. A prostitute took such a way to earn is or her daily bread. They are also human beings we should consider that also. That are our cohabitants we have to give them at least that care. This is my conclusion to this topic.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Dr. S. R. Myneni, Sociology for Law Students, Allahabad Law Agency Faridabad, 2021
- Vidya Bhushan, An Introduction To Sociology, Kitab Mahal, 2020
- https://indiankanoon.org/
- https://blog.ipleaders.in/
- https://www.britannica.com/
[1] (1915) ILR 38 Mad 1144(1915(1915) ILR 38 Mad 1144) ILR 38 Mad 1144
[2] AIR 1990 AP 100
[3] 42 Ind Cas 556, (1917) 33 MLJ 224