RESOLUTION WITHOUT JUDGMENT: WHEN SETTLEMENT REPLACES JUSTICE
Abstract
RESOLUTION WITHOUT JUDGMENT: WHEN SETTLEMENT REPLACES JUSTICE
AUTHOR – CHETAN KUMAR DEEP, STUDENT AT SYMBIOSIS LAW SCHOOL PUNE
BEST CITATION - CHETAN KUMAR DEEP, RESOLUTION WITHOUT JUDGMENT: WHEN SETTLEMENT REPLACES JUSTICE ILE JOURNAL OF ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION LAW REVIEW (ILE JADRLR), 3 (1) OF 2025, PG. 14-29, APIS – 3920 – 0046 | ISSN – 2584-2005.
Abstract
The growing reliance on out-of-court settlements has significantly reshaped contemporary dispute resolution, particularly in jurisdictions burdened by judicial delay and increasing case complexity. While such settlements are often celebrated for their efficiency, flexibility, and capacity to reduce judicial backlog, their normative implications for justice delivery remain under-examined. This paper critically evaluates whether out-of-court settlements are merely a pragmatic response to judicial inefficiency or whether their expanding role risks diluting the core functions of adjudication. It argues that unlike court judgments, settlements do not result in authoritative determinations of rights and liabilities, nor do they contribute to the development of legal precedent. Consequently, although victims may receive compensation or closure, they may be deprived of substantive justice, public accountability, and legal vindication. At the same time, the paper acknowledges that with the increasing technical and commercial complexity of disputes, expert-driven settlement mechanisms such as arbitration and mediation are both necessary and desirable. Through doctrinal analysis, judicial observations, and comparative perspectives, the paper contends that the problem lies not in the existence of out-of-court settlements but in their overuse as substitutes for adjudication. It concludes that settlements must function as complementary mechanisms rather than replacements for judicial decision-making, in order to preserve justice, precedent, and the law-declaring role of courts.
Keywords: Out-of-court settlement, judicial delay, access to justice, ADR, court efficiency.