DISOBEYING THE ORDER OF PUBLIC SERVANT
Abstract
DISOBEYING THE ORDER OF PUBLIC SERVANT
AUTHOR - SRIJAN GUPTA, STUDENT AT IILM (INSTITUTE OF INTEGRATED LEARNING IN MANAGEMENT) UNIVERSITY
BEST CITATION - SRIJAN GUPTA, DISOBEYING THE ORDER OF PUBLIC SERVANT, ILE MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL, 5 (1) OF 2026, PG. 08-13, APIS – 3920-0007 | ISSN - 2583-7230.
ABSTRACT
In order for a large democratic country such as India to function effectively, all citizens must comply with the lawful instructions given to them by their public officers. Historically, the act of not following these lawful instructions has been criminalised under the Indian Penal Code (IPC) to discourage civil disobedience, prevent risks to health and safety, and to remove impediments to the administration of justice. The repeal of the IPC and introduction of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) Act (2023) represents a radical remake of the legal structure which will govern these offences; namely, the transfer from Section 188 of the IPC will now be governed by Section 223 of the BNS Act.
The legal framework's development has been modernized while still striving to create a system of laws that supports state authority. Effective since October 2023, a valid act of insubordination can only be basis on an order given by a public servant who is legally authorized to do so in accordance with Sub. No. 223. Further, there is a distinction between simple acts of insubordination that can result in only "interference or annoyance" and more serious acts that directly threaten 'life, health or safety to others.'
The judiciary serves as a bulwark against the possible abuse of power through administrative overreach. Courts have consistently recognized that these provisions should not be used as tools of "executive tyranny". Pursuant to BNSS (Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita), existing procedural protections remain in place that requires a public official to submit a written complaint to initiate proceedings rather than simply being able to file a FIR when reporting the violation. Only in situations where there is a risk to public peace cans this law be enforced. This article will address the elements necessary for conviction under the BNS; how communication in the digital age affects the "knowledge" requirement needed to order compliance; and how to strike an acceptable balance between enforcing the administrative rule and protecting the fundamental right to dissent within the context of India.