LEGAL INSANITY AS A PLEA OF DEFENCE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS UNDER SECTION 84 OF THE INDIAN PENAL CODE
Abstract
LEGAL INSANITY AS A PLEA OF DEFENCE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS UNDER SECTION 84 OF THE INDIAN PENAL CODE
AUTHOR - SADIYA ALI* & PARAS YADAV**
* ADVOCATE & LLM STUDENT AT IILM UNIVERSITY GREATER NOIDA
** ASSISTANT PROFESSOR AT IILM UNIVERSITY GREATER NOIDA
BEST CITATION - SADIYA ALI & PARAS YADAV, LEGAL INSANITY AS A PLEA OF DEFENCE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS UNDER SECTION 84 OF THE INDIAN PENAL CODE, ILE MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL, 5 (1) OF 2026, PG. 52-65, APIS โ 3920-0007 | ISSN - 2583-7230.
ABSTRACT
The basic principle upon which the criminal justice system functions is that criminal liability will arise only in cases where there is a presence of two elementsโactus reus and mens rea; however, in the absence of mens rea, criminal responsibility will be ruled out. But this principle is subject to an exception, which states that in case an individual suffers from certain mental disability and, therefore, cannot generate criminal intention, the defence of insanity can be raised against him.
In India, this rule is provided for by Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code, whereby any person will be considered free of criminal liability when, at the time of doing the act, he was of unsound mind and incapable of either comprehending the nature of his acts or their being wrong. This section embodies the doctrine of legal insanity, according to which what matters is not the medical definition of insanity but the mental state of the accused at the time of commission of the crime.
A timeline of the development of the insanity defense can be made with the help of judicial precedents. In R v. Arnold (1724), โWild Beast Testโ was formed according to which a defendant was not liable for his actions if he was unable to understand the nature of his act just like a beast could not understand what it did when it bit somebody. In R v. Hadfield (1800), โInsane Delusion Testโ was established, stating that an act under delusion cannot be held criminally responsible. Another example is R v. Bowler (1812) focusing on whether the person knew the difference between right and wrong at the time of committing the crime. All these precedents led to the historic case of M'Naghten's Case (1843).
Apart from being addressed in criminal law statutes, the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 provides an innovative framework to protect people with mental illnesses. The Act defines mental illnesses as those which substantially disturb the functioning of the brain in matters relating to cognition, mood, perception, and memory, which interfere with his judgment and his capacity to deal with the demands of everyday life. Importantly, it effectively decriminalizes attempted suicide by overriding Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code, acknowledging that such individuals require care and treatment rather than punishment.
However, despite these safeguards, the defence of insanity also brings up issues about its possible abuse since there is a possibility that the accused will try to feign insanity in order to avoid criminal liability. It is the duty of the accused, therefore, to prove insanity by a preponderance of probability.
In summary, the defence of insanity reflects the delicate interplay of justice and humanitarianism within the law. With the clear differentiation between legal and medical insanity, as well as the determination of sanity during the commission of the crime, the law has made sure that those who have the ability to discern right from wrong will be held responsible for their actions while ensuring that those who lack such ability receive appropriate treatment.